Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


St John of God - Marylands - Index


2006/1 - The trial of Bernard McGrath

 




The Press
February 28 2006

Brother said abuse all right - witness
by John Henzell

A former Marylands schoolboy claims he was told "this is what Catholics do" while he was sexually abused by a Catholic brother.

The boy, now a middle-aged man, told the High Court in Christchurch the abuse happened only once, when dorm master Brother Bernard Kevin McGrath lay on top of him in bed and moved up and down.

McGrath, 58, denies 53 charges of sodomy and indecency involving 16 boys at the boarding school for troubled youths on the outskirts of Christchurch in the mid 1970s.

The jury was told McGrath had been jailed before for sexually abusing boys and it was accepted that Marylands boys were sexually abused by Catholic brothers from the St John of God order. McGrath claims he has already admitted the full extent of his offending.

The former schoolboy yesterday spoke with a slurred voice and had trouble walking because of the injuries he sustained in a 1987 assault .

He told the court yesterday he had been asleep in his bed when he was woken by McGrath.

"I had my bed covers on me and he got on top of me for five minutes to half an hour and up and down, up and down, up and down," he said.

"He said `this is what Catholics do. It's all right'.

"He was supposed to be a brother – supposed to be – but as far as I'm concerned he wasn't. He was supposed to keep an eye on the kids but after what he did to me ... it makes no sense."

McGrath was positioned in a way that their groins were rubbing against each other through the bedclothes.

Prosecutor Chris Lange asked if he had told anyone about the incident.

The man replied: "No, because he said that's what Catholics do and it's all right. I didn't say anything about it because I was terrified."

He said he told nobody about what happened until he saw television coverage of McGrath's child molesting charges from the 1990s. He made a complaint to Christchurch police but nothing happened.

Raoul Neave, for McGrath, said the police had no record of a complaint being made, but the man insisted it was true.

Neave: "You'd seen the St John of God order was offering money and you'd seen that it was Brother McGrath who was one of the people they were looking into."

He agreed.

Neave: "The problems you've got today relate to an incident in 1987 when you were very savagely beaten up. You were left very seriously injured by that attack – in fact, you're probably lucky to be here."

The man replied: "Absolutely. Eight times I died and it left me with severe paralysis on my right-hand side."

"And some brain damage as well?"

"Yes."

Neave: "This person (who abused touched you), are you sure it was Brother McGrath?"

The man replied: "Yes. He's sitting right behind you. Brother Bernard McGrath."

The trial continues today.