Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


St John of God - Marylands - Index


2006/1 - The trial of Bernard McGrath

 




The Press
March 17 2006

Trial attempt to regain faith

Anne Hudson-Ramage does not know for sure if childhood sexual abuse by Catholic brothers at Marylands school prompted her son's suicide 11 years ago.

But the grieving mother from Timaru knew she had to attend Bernard McGrath's trial to reach some kind of peace with her lapsed Catholic faith after hearing about the culture of paedophilia at the school in the 1970s.

"God and I haven't been on talking terms for four years," she said, after watching McGrath being found guilty of sexually molesting eight boys who were at the school at the same time as her son.

"I attended the trial to find some resolution for myself and to resolve my issues with God and to get back to my faith, if I can."

Hudson-Ramage had battled to get her mildly retarded son admitted to Marylands because he could not get the kind of education he needed from the schools at their then home in Roxburgh. He spent eight years at the school, between 1967 and 1975.

She thought the strict Catholic school would be good for him and had no inkling that there was what the St John of God Order now accepts to have been a network of clergy and brethren molesting children and protecting each other.

Her son killed himself soon after learning that McGrath had been jailed for sexual abuse at a Catholic school in Australia, to which McGrath had been sent from Marylands.

Hudson-Ramage said she could accept that there were some child-molesting men at the school but found it far more difficult to live with the knowledge that other brethren and clergy failed to raise the alarm.

"For evil to succeed to such an extent, all that's required is for good men to do nothing. There were good men at Marylands -- and they did nothing," she said.

"I've had some closure, just from listening to McGrath's videotaped interview. I think I'm stronger."

Hudson-Ramage was hugged by Ken Clearwater, manager of the Male Survivors of Sexual Abuse Trust, who is working with nearly 40 men who have reported being sexually abused while attending Marylands. Five were complainants in the trial.

Clearwater said he was pleased the jury had returned 21 guilty verdicts but would have to talk to the men over the next few days about the mixed success of the prosecution.

"Right from the word go, the prosecution and the defence said atrocities happened to children at the school. This isn't the end."