Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse of Prisoners by Police - Main Index


News Reports - 3

 



Otago Daily Times
March 4 2005

Police boss moves to qualify harsh words
NZPA


  

From left: Steve Shortland;  Ron Mark


Wellington: Counties Manukau District Commander Superintendent Steve Shortland said yesterday a harsh newsletter he wrote criticising staff who leaked information to the media was not directed at genuine whistleblowers.

New Zealand First law and order spokesman Ron Mark accused Supt Shortland of launching a witch-hunt against whistle-blowers and criticised the “intemperate” language in the newsletter.

Supt Shortland encouraged police officers to dob in colleagues running to the media with information.

“If you know someone who fits the bill, and you feel strongly about it, I would like to hear from you.”

Supt Shortland wrote the newsletter after the New Zealand Herald contacted Counties Manukau Police for comment about claims made by an unnamed police source there was an internal disciplinary problem when a sergeant refused to obey the orders of a senior sergeant.

“The traitorous actions of this person amount to some offences that can be dealt with as disciplinary offences,” he said.

Quoting a police ethics booklet, Supt Shortland said people who became “traitors” did it for personal gain — such as money, a free lunch or sex — or out of stupidity.

Mr Mark said Supt Shortland’s comments were out of order.

“What gives the commander the right to bully and abuse someone for alerting the public to something they did not think was right,” he asked.

But Supt Shortland said yesterday his comments were not directed at officers with genuine concerns, only those who “maliciously and scurrilously” leaked information to the media.

“Some people may see it as a witch-hunt. Others will see it is an attempt to prevent malicious and scurrilous leaks to the media in pursuit of a personal agenda,” Supt Shortland said.

“We were unable to comment at the time as we did not have details on the incident. Subsequent inquiries established that there was no argument and that the matter had been blown out of proportion by the media and the ‘police source’,” Supt Shortland said.

The leak was designed to embarrass police, he said.

“These type of media leaks are not common but had the potential to do enormous damage to investigations, both internal and criminal, and effect police morale.”

He emphasised the newsletter was not directed at officers with serious concerns.