Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Psychiatric Hospitals Index


July-Dec 2004 Index

 



Stuff
August 2 2004

Govt seeks ways for abused patients to avoid court cases
NZPA

Attorney-General Margaret Wilson says she is exploring ways for former psychiatric patients to avoid court cases if they want to when they seek compensation for their abuse claims.

The historic allegations surfaced earlier this year and cover claims of widespread mistreatment at most of New Zealand's mental hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s.

Ms Wilson said yesterday that so far 68 individual claims had been filed in the High Court and she understood more than 300 people had not yet filed.

"We believe there is much merit in exploring ideas that allow claimants and the Government to resolve these claims other than through litigation," she said in a statement.

"At this stage the Government is still talking to claimants and specific options have not been finalised."

Ms Wilson said any option that allowed former patients and staff to air their grievances and experiences in a place other than an open court was worthwhile considering.

"Going to court is always an option," she said.

"It is, however, a forum where liability and blame are attributed through adversarial means.

"This may not be appropriate or helpful for many former patients, staff, and their families. We have to make sure we do the best thing for everyone concerned." Ms Wilson said that while the idea of alternatives to litigation was being explored, the Government had a public accountability not to pay out money on claims unless it was established that there was a good reason to do so.

A coalition of psychiatric "survivor" groups called on Friday for a formal process to hear the claims.

Coalition spokeswoman Helen Gilbert said New Zealand could adopt similar redress procedures to those developed in Canada and Ireland.

"What we are looking for is a fair and just process to hear our stories and provide us with appropriate compensation," she said.