Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Salvation Army Homes - Main Index


Index 2003 (Jan-Aug)




The Daily News
August 26 2003

Danger in judging yesterday by today
Letter to the Editor
by W A West, New Plymouth

I was pleased to see the article, headed "Ex-Sallies boy backs church" (August 23), and I respect Mr Parker's stand on this matter.

I would hate to see the good work New Zealand's 120-year-old Salvation Army and other organisations do over-shadowed by the hype that I'm sure will occur over the current wave of "abuse" accusations.

I know a lot of the men who once lived in the Eltham home for boys, and we have to acknowledge that this organisation took over the role of parents when circumstances meant families had to be separated, in some cases for many years.

Times have changed. What is now considered abuse was, in that era, accepted discipline, whether in the home or school. We were disciplined with the strap or, in my case, a stick of supplejack. The local policeman tugged at my ear and booted my backside, and, if I went home and told my Dad, another kick would follow from him.

Many children started work at 5am, milking cows, walking to school, and milking again when they got home. Should we now be calling this "child slave labour"? No, we worked because that was expected of us.

I attended a New Plymouth school where a teacher put tacks in the end of the strap and hit the boys until their wrists bled. Perhaps we should now sue the Education Department.

I hope all the lawyers who are rubbing their hands in glee will find someone else to pick on.

To all those who attended such orphanages, I presume it was the last place you wanted to be, but I wonder where you and your families would be today if not for this care.