Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




Stuff
August 2 2005

Woman collapses in witness box during sex abuse case
NZPA

A woman suing the Catholic church over alleged physical and sexual abuse collapsed in the witness box at the High Court in Wellington today, halting the hearing.

Earlier the woman hurled a folder of documents toward a lawyer and screamed, swore and cried under questioning.

The 45-year-old woman is claiming $550,000 in a civil suit against the Wellington Catholic Archdiocese, Catholic Social Services, The Sisters of Mercy (Wellington) Trust Board, and St Joseph's Orphanage Trust Board over alleged abuse.

The respondents' lawyer had been questioning her about her alleged rape by a male member of a foster family approved by the church, she had stayed with in the mid-1970s.

The woman began screaming when asked when and where she stayed with the family,

She yelled: "Jesus ... I'm not an animal."

Justice Marion Frater adjourned the court for a few minutes after the woman jumped off her seat and threw a folder.

When court resumed, the woman said: "I am sorry for being a naughty Girl ... I'm trying to be a good girl."

She went on to describe how she was allegedly raped by the male after a Sunday group meeting at a church.

A short time later the woman collapsed in the witness box prompting the judge to again adjourn the hearing.

Yesterday, the woman broke down in court when asked to describe how she was allegedly made to perform oral sex on a priest.

She said she was about eight years old when it happened at St Joseph's Orphanage in Upper Hutt, where she lived between 1968 and 1973.

The woman, whose name is suppressed, claims she was beaten unconscious by nuns, verbally and mentally abused, told she would go straight to Hell, and made to feel worthless at the orphanage.

One nun hit her head, causing an ear injury that was not corrected surgically until she left school, and more sexual abuse took place at private homes she was sent to for holidays, she alleges.

A psychiatrist had diagnosed the woman as having a cluster of syndromes and disorders, the woman's counsel Helen Cull told the court.

Few such cases against religious groups reached the court, most had been settled out of court, Ms Cull said.

The respondents have denied the woman's claims in papers filed in court. They also say ACC rules mean she cannot claim for injuries that ACC covers, and that she is in any event too late to make the claims she does.

The case is set down for three weeks before Justice Marion Frater, who has ordered the suppression of most witnesses' names until judgement