Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




One News
August 4 2005

Woman suing church over alleged abuse

A lawyer for the Catholic Church has suggested to the High Court at Wellington that a serious ear injury suffered by a woman suing the church for alleged abuse was caused by infection, and not by a blow.

The 45-year-old wants compensation of more than half a million dollars for abuse she says she suffered at an Upper Hutt orphanage, St Mary's College in Wellington, and in foster homes.

The complainant has told the court that she was beaten around the ear by a nun at St Mary's who found her copying another girls handwriting from a book and that she lived with a perforated ear drum for nearly ten years.

An Australian ear specialist who examined her told the court by video link that the injury was almost certainly caused by a blow because of its location.

However the lawyer for the orphanage and the college Chris Finlayson said another doctor believed it was much more likely to have been caused by a chronic infection in childhood.