Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




The Dominion Post
August 5 2005

Abuse claimant 'caught in past'
Woman said she needed time to recover from recollections

A woman who says nuns hit and abused her at Catholic schools and an orphanage needed time to "get back" from the places she was talking about while giving evidence from the witness stand.

"I am on the stairs, you have got to let me get out of the stairs," she told lawyer Chris Finlayson.

The woman, who has name suppression, was still caught in the past when he tried to ask his next question. "Can I get down from the stairs please," she asked.

Yesterday was her third and final day giving evidence in the High Court at Wellington in her $550,000 claim against four Catholic organisations. Mr Finlayson, acting for The Sisters of Mercy (Wellington) Trust Board and St Joseph's Orphanage Trust Board, said witnesses would give evidence contradicting what the woman said about the way she was treated at St Joseph's and St Mary's College in the 1960s and 70s.

The woman is also suing Wellington's Roman Catholic Archdiocese and Catholic Social Services.

At St Mary's, where she boarded, the woman said all her belongings fitted into a suitcase. She agreed records showed money was spent on clothes and other items, but said she had very few possessions.

A nun had arranged for her to have an eye test but nothing was done for an ear injury that she claimed happened when a nun at St Joseph's hit her across the side of the head. The assault is denied, and the defendants say infection was the more likely cause of her perforated eardrum. The woman's expert witness says a blow was almost certainly the cause.

She said nuns at St Joseph's had better food than the children. "Can I show you where we used to throw the food out the window . . . Bloody tripe and stuff like that."

Mr Finlayson asked more questions but the woman was still thinking about the food. "I am just looking at that tripe. Oh my God."

After more questions the woman said she was again in the past. "Hang on, I'm in the coat room and you have got to let me get out."

Recalling hair washing also took her back. "Let me get out of the bathroom please," she said when Mr Finlayson asked his next question. "I told you I am chocka, and let me please come out of where I am."

The woman's sister is to give evidence today.