Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




Otago Daily Times
August 16 2005

Ex-social worker admits taking no action
NZPA

Wellington: A retired social worker has admitted not taking any action even though she considered a teenager highly institutionalised and socially deprived.

The now 82-year-old gave evidence yesterday via video link from Auckland to the High Court at Wellington, where one of her former clients is suing four Catholic groups for $550,000.

The woman who has brought the case, and her six siblings, was put into Catholic care by her mother when her parents’ marriage broke up in the 1960s.

She says she was verbally, physically, emotionally and sexually abused in the years that followed while in the care of the Sisters of Mercy at St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt, and St Marys College, Wellington.

The Sisters trust board, the orphanage trust board, Catholic Social Services and Wellington’s Roman Catholic Archdiocese are defending the claim.

Evidence from Catholic Social Services (CSS), the archdiocese’s main social agency, has been that nuns had day-to-day care of the girl.

Yesterday’s witness, whose name was suppressed, was a CSS social worker. She did not know what legal connection CSS had to children in its care.

In early 1972, she was asked to “keep an eye” on the claimant, whose name is also suppressed. The nuns remained in control and she had no authority to ask questions about what happened at the orphanage, she said.

During 1973, she noted signs of social deprivation. A foster family placement lasted a few months. The father thought she was obsessed with sexual matters.

Earlier that year, a holiday host had found the claimant’s “adolescent crush” on her husband hard to deal with.

The claimant’s lawyer, Helen Cull QC, asked what steps she took to address the series of problems. The witness said that one-by-one they were not unexpected, and, at the time, she did not think outside help was needed.

The case is continuing.