Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




Dominion Post
August 17 2005

Abuse claimant was 'demanding'

A teenager who had spent years in institutional care did not always understand "boundaries" that family life required, a former foster father says.

In the High Court at Wellington yesterday, the man, whose name was suppressed, said he once turned off the hot water when she had been too long in the shower, and flicked her hand with the flat side of a knife when she picked at meat as he was carving a roast. The teenager concerned is now 45 and is suing four Catholic organisations for $550,000 for emotional, verbal, physical and sexual abuse she says she suffered while growing up.

The defendants, Wellington's Roman Catholic Archdiocese, Catholic Social Services, The Sisters of Mercy (Wellington) Trust Board, and St Joseph's Orphanage Trust Board, deny her claims on factual and legal grounds. The claimant has been diagnosed with a range of psychiatric and emotional problems. Her parents separated in the 1960s and her mother put the seven children into care.

The man who gave evidence yesterday said the claimant arrived at his home in early 1977 after boarding at St Mary's College. The move reunited her with one of her sisters, who was one of eight children living in the house. The man told one of the claimant's lawyers, Nicolette Levy, that he was not told specifically of problems resulting from the claimant being institutionalised, but he and his wife had a general idea because her sister had problems.

Catholic Social Services gave the couple a $15 a week subsidy for each girl, and chits to buy clothes. The couple paid for presents and holidays and CSS paid extra for the girl's driving lessons, sports clothes, and a dress and tickets for a ball. She was happy while she stayed with them but was demanding and did not always understand the sort of boundaries that came with being in a large family, the man said.

He and his wife gave her $1000 and paid other expenses when she returned to New Zealand in 2000. They gave up their bed when she and her two sons stayed for several weeks.