Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse in NZ Institutions - Main Index


St Josephs Orphanage, Upper Hutt

 




The Dominion Post
August 20 2005

Nun denies slapping child

A nun has denied damaging the eardrum of a child in her care by slapping the side of her head more than 30 years ago.

The assault claim is one of the allegations a woman, 45, whose name is suppressed, has made against Sisters of Mercy nuns in the High Court at Wellington.

The claimant, who is suing four Catholic organisations for $550,000, says the sister, whose name is also suppressed, slapped her after catching her looking at another girl's schoolbook at St Joseph's Orphanage, Upper Hutt.

She said that for years her ear was sore, sometimes with a discharge, and that she was given no medical attention till it was fixed surgically after she left school.

The nun yesterday denied slapping her.

The claimant, who had little contact with her parents after their marriage ended, lived at St Joseph's Orphanage from 1968 to 1973 and spent several months with foster parents before boarding for three years at St Mary's College, Wellington, from 1974.

She says she was emotionally, verbally and physically abused by nuns, and that a priest sexually abused her at St Joseph's, her grandfather sexually abused her when she visited him, and other men sexually abused her during holidays that Catholic Social Services arranged.

She has sued Wellington's Roman Catholic Archdiocese, its social agency, Catholic Social Services, the Sisters of Mercy (Wellington) Trust Board, and St Joseph's Orphanage Trust Board.

After three weeks, the hearing was adjourned yesterday till September 5 when more nuns are expected to give evidence.

The nun accused of injuring the claimant's ear said the sisters tried to make the orphanage a home for the children. She did not remember using corporal punishment, or shouting at or abusing children. She did not see anyone else beat a child, she said.

She remembered the claimant being an unhappy child and feeling sorry for her and her two sisters when their mother failed to take them for a holiday as promised.