Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(4) Oct 8-9 2004 Index

 



Dominion Post
October 8 2004

'They lined up 30 guys and gave me a kicking'
by Paul Mulrooney and Hank Schouten

A former army cadet who was being given medical attention at the time one of his fellow cadets was shot dead in 1981 says that repeated abuse "completely skewed" his view of military life.

More than 20 years after enduring months of alleged physical and psychological abuse at Waiouru Cadet School, David Cruickshank said the cadet corporal who pulled the trigger that day was as much a victim of the brutal environment as the cadet he shot.

An army court of inquiry report, only now made public, has confirmed allegations made this week that cadets were beaten and abused. Grant Bain, 17, was shot by a cadet corporal after an altercation in their barracks.

When Mr Bain was shot there was no adult duty supervisor present. The supervisor was attending to Mr Cruickshank, then aged 16, who was in the camp hospital bleeding and badly bruised after being kicked by fellow cadets for making a mistake on the parade ground.

"They lined up 30 or 40 guys on either side of me and I had to walk down the middle and each one of them was told to kick me up the backside with their steel-capped boots as hard as they could."

Mr Cruickshank was taken to the camp hospital with blood coming from his backside. Midway through the treatment, his supervisor left suddenly for the barracks.

"He was of course dealing with what happened to my mate Bain. He was in the same barracks room as me."

The shooting, by 17-year-old cadet corporal Andrew William Read, who had ordered the earlier punishment, should never have happened as live rounds were forbidden in the barracks, Mr Cruickshank said. Other punishments he remembers include:

* Being made to stand on one foot on the parade ground, holding his rifle at arms length while an officer cadet picked his nose with a knife.

* Having floor polish rubbed in his hair. After it solidified the only way to remove it was to have all his hair cut off.

* Being coerced into "pimping" on fellow cadets and in retribution being ambushed at night, having a blanket thrown over him and being beaten.

The climate of violence went unremarked by most cadets, who believed it to be part of the training.

"Because we were so young we were given a view this must be what the army is like because we had nothing else to compare it to," Mr Cruickshank said.

After the fatal shooting, Read "took off into the hills for a day or so" before Mr Bain's funeral was held. Read was charged by police with careless use of a firearm causing death. He pleaded guilty and was fined $200 and ordered to do 200 hours' community work.

Cadets were told the shooting was an accident and everybody was interviewed, Mr Cruickshank said. They were asked whether they wanted to stay. Mr Cruickshank decided to leave.

"I was in shock – I didn't want to be in the army . . . and when I got out my parents told me later I was a real mess."

He understood the need for discipline but it was taken to extremes, he said.

"We were guys who had just come out of school."

He went into the army hoping to get training and a career but it came to nothing, he said. What happened had affected his life for years.

"I had nightmares and had a drinking problem for many years. It ended up impacting on jobs, relationships, the whole lot. It was just terrible."