Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(5) Oct 17- Dec 31 2004 Index

 



The Press
October 23 2004

Approval for Waiouru inquiry
by Vernon Small

The man who triggered an investigation into alleged abuse at the Army cadet school in Waiouru says he is "relatively comfortable" with limited details of an inquiry released yesterday.

The Government has appointed former High Court Judge David Morris as independent assessor to look into the alleged abuse at the former Regular Force Cadet School, but it will be another week before the terms of reference for the ministerial inquiry are made public.

Defence Minister Mark Burton said Morris would "separate issues of mistreatment from more serious allegations that, even in the context of time, may amount to criminal offences".

The claims date back 25 to 45 years.

A ministerial inquiry does not have the power to summon witnesses or take evidence under oath.

Former army sergeant Ian Fraser, who yesterday said he had received about 350 allegations of abuse since he first raised concerns about behaviour at the school, said Morris seemed a good choice.

"He certainly doesn't appear to be an establishment figure. He appears to be a free thinker and someone who isn't afraid of stirring up a bit of controversy so yes, I am quite happy with the appointment."

Morris had been involved with the national Women's Hospital cervical cancer inquiry, the Erebus Commission of Inquiry and investigations into the Mr Asia drug ring.

Fraser said he would have preferred an inquiry which could have summoned witnesses and taken evidence on oath. Some witnesses may have a guilty conscience and might not want to give evidence.

"They would be doing themselves no favours."

After discussions with Burton's office he was satisfied with the explanation that a commission of inquiry would have taken much longer. He would be consulted over the terms of reference before they were released.

He had also been assured Police Minister George Hawkins would co- operate with the inquiry if the assessor needed to look at police documents.

Burton said the army would fully co-operate with the inquiry "making available all relevant existing information in a timely manner".

A spokeswoman said some records may not be available because they must be destroyed after a set time.

She agreed that meant it may not be possible to ascertain if someone had already been disciplined for the kind of behaviour complained about.

"The army has been forthcoming in terms of going into their archives and getting out everything to date that we've needed. So whatever Justice Morris thinks he needs to look for in the archives they will find and produce as quickly as possible."

--------------------

CAPTION: Mark Burton