Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(9)  Dec 2005 (Report Released)

 




Waikato Times
December 6 2005

Report into cadet bullying does not go far enough - whistleblower
by Andrew McAlley

The man who blew the whistle on abuse at the army's former cadet school says the report by retired High Court judge David Morris was damning but didn't go far enough.

The report found bullying took place at the Regular Force Cadet School but said there was nothing to support claims of a culture of abuse.

Speaking from his home in Australia, former sergeant Ian Fraser said: "What planet are these people on if they don't believe the judge's findings of a pervasive pattern of violence existing means a culture of abuse?"

Mr Fraser said the army had failed in an effort to put a positive spin on the report.

More than 80 former cadets were interviewed by Justice Morris, but Mr Fraser said he had been in contact with more than 300.

"Why, time after time, when cadets were asked if they reported abuse did they say `no'?

"The reason they said `no' was because they were scared," he said.

Mr Fraser sparked the probe last year when he posted on the internet an article outlining physical and sexual abuse of cadets between the 1960s and 1980s.

The article led to more than 300 other cadets coming forward and was the catalyst for an investigation into the abuse and into the death of cadet Grant Bain.

The 17-year-old, from Te Awamutu, died in the cadet barracks after being shot by fellow cadet Andrew Read in 1981.

But former army recruiter Mike Subritzky, of Te Awamutu, thought the report's findings were fair.

"There was no army-wide culture of bullying. Incidents happened some years and in others it didn't depending on the calibre of senior cadets at the time," he said.

Retired army officer Wayne Anker, who commanded the cadet school in 1982, said he had prepared himself for the worst when the report was published.

But he said the report was fair.

"Really the findings were pretty good. There were obvious problems with the handling of the Bain case but Justice Morris has done a pretty thorough job," he said.