Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(9)  Dec 2005 (Report Released)

 




The Dominion Post
December 9 2005

Cadet's family want answers
by Hank Schouten

The police and army have been asked to provide more information about the investigation into the fatal shooting of army cadet Grant Bain in his Waiouru barracks 24 years ago.

The request was made yesterday when Mr Bain's brother Murray met with Defence Minister Phil Goff, army chief Jerry Mateparae and Deputy Police Commissioner Steve Long.

Mr Bain said the family was pleased with the inquiry findings of former High Court judge David Morris. Cadet Corporal Andrew Read had loaded his rifle and shot Grant Bain in the head, and the inquiry found Read should have been charged with manslaughter instead of the minor charge of careless use of a firearm.

The family was also pleased that the army needed to take responsibility for what happened. However, they were disappointed that Justice Morris found there was no evidence of collusion between the police and army on the charge to be laid. Read's penalty was 200 hours of community service on the charge of careless use. He died in a forestry accident in 1998.

Mr Bain said the police had completed an internal review after matters were raised by the family but had yet to receive the results.

National MP Shane Ardern said the Bain family had come to him five years ago and "the further I go into this matter the more I realise this family have been done a rough deal by a number of government agencies".

"It's my role to see that wrong has been righted and in my view we are two- thirds of the way down that process."

He said Mr Goff was surprised by some of the additional information given to him by the family and about how little he had been advised on the matter.

All the issues needed to be dealt with to find a resolution that would bring closure to the family, Mr Ardern said.

The Government needed to look at all the facts and suggest a way forward to the family. Family members had also been asked to think about what they would need for closure.

Mr Goff said he had a useful meeting with Mr Bain, who outlined the family's concerns. He undertook to seek further information and to refer back to Mr Bain.

* A report yesterday wrongly attributed comments in the army abuse inquiry report to former police commissioner Bob Walton. The sections of the report quoted were in fact excerpts from an interview Justice Morris had with another senior police officer.