www.peterellis.co.nz : seeking justice for Peter Ellis : mail to: [email protected]

Accusations of Abuse in Institutions

 

Index: Home Page Peter Ellis
Index: Accusations in Institutions


Sunday Star Times
March 3, 2002

Church in sex claims
by Amanda Cropp

The Anglican Church is facing hefty compensation claims from women who say they were sexually harassed and abused by an Anglican priest.

Although the church has denied legal liability, it has now agreed to consider paying compensation if the women concerned undergo psychiatric assessment.


Two women are seeking between $160,000 and $180,000 each for counselling and other costs arising from alleged abuse by Rob McCullough.

Complaints about sexual misconduct by McCullough, once a high profile Christchurch priest, go back to 1989 when a group of women alerted church leaders.

The two women are angry about delays in settling the matter and say there are strong parallels with the sex scandals rocking the Anglican Church in Australia.

Governor-general Peter Hollingworth has been called on to resign over claims he covered up sex abuse by priests and church officials when he was archbishop of Brisbane.

The bishop of Christchurch, David Coles, confirmed the church has received a number of claims for "compensation of varying sorts" in relation to the former rev McCullough. It is understood financial claims have been lodged by three or four women, while others are seeking a formal apology from the church.

Coles said the church was negotiating with two lawyers representing the women. He said QC Nigel Hampton was retained on behalf of some of the complainants and the church had agreed to pay some of his costs to ensure the complainants had access to high quality legal advice. The church has also retained lawyers, including QC Tom Weston, to act on its behalf. Bishop Coles said agreement had been reached with one of the lawyers over a process to try to resolve some claims but he would not elaborate on what that involved.

At last year's synod, bishop Coles offered "heartfelt and sincere apologies to all the women who had suffered abuse at the hands of this priest" and said that since November 2000 there had been constant activity to determine "an appropriate and just response to the women who were abused".

In the wake of the first complaints the church removed McCullough's licence to officiate as a priest, he lost all positions within the church, was banned from supervising women alone and required to undertake regular therapy. He has not worked for the church since. McCullough's wife told the Star-Times he had had no information on the claims and no one from the church was in touch with him. She said her husband would not wish to comment.

One complainant said the attitude of the Australian church was very similar to what the women here had experienced. "All along the church has acted defensively and not with compassion. If they had apologised I would not have asked for money. The original wrong has been compounded to such an extent by the way the church has handled (my complaint) that I now need compensation in order to put it behind me and get on with my life.

"I don't know how much more of this process I can cope with."

The woman, an ordained minister, said she had been unable to get work in her profession and had to retrain. "We were vilified. People were describing me as a harlot, a dangerous sexually predatory woman. People were saying things like 'never be alone in a room with her'. I had terrible experiences of people saying 'don't even bother applying for this job, we'll just screw up your application and throw it in the bin'."

Last year a Supreme Court jury ordered the Anglican Diocese of Brisbane to pay more than $830,000 damages to a female former student who was abused by a boarding master at a preparatory school. This case is important, say some of the New Zealand complainants, because it shows the church can be held accountable for sexual misconduct by ministers and other church staff.

When the church was alerted to McCullough's behaviour he was head of College House, a University of Canterbury hostel. He was also responsible for theological training and prepared candidates for ordination.

In her book Whistle Blower published last year Canterbury priest Louise Deans says she and other women abused by McCullough (he was not named in the book) called for compensation of $60,000 each from the College House Trust Board to match the amount paid to McCullough when he resigned from his job.

Six months ago two complaints, one of sexual assault and one of rape, were laid against McCullough with Christchurch police. A detective sergeant concluded there was no criminal liability.