Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Police Rape Allegations - Main Index


Jan - Feb 2005

 














Standing firm: Louise Nicholas says the wait while police investigated her claims was frustrating. `For us it's not a matter of if, it's a matter of when, but when has taken a hell of a long time to get here.' (Kent Blechynden)












Dominion Post
January 15 2005

Decision close on police rape claims
By Haydon Dewes

Police are on the brink of deciding whether to lay criminal charges against three men accused of raping Louise Nicholas while serving as police officers.

They have also, for the first time, released details showing the scale of their complex investigation – dubbed Operation Austin – which has grown to include complaints against others, and which has so far cost the taxpayer $1.4 million.

Crown Law solicitors are evaluating the weight of information collected by police since allegations were published exclusively in The Dominion Post last January that Mrs Nicholas was pack-raped and violated with a police baton by three officers as a teenager in 1986.

Mrs Nicholas named Assistant Police Commissioner Clint Rickards and former officers Bob Schollum and Brad Shipton as the three men involved. They all vehemently deny the allegations.

Mr Rickards stepped down from duty the day after the allegations were made. He remains stood down, on full pay.

Police are also investigating allegations that the incident was covered up by John Dewar, a senior Rotorua detective who befriended Mrs Nicholas at the time she first raised the allegations, to protect the trio.

Police confirmed yesterday the investigation was in its final stages. They would not say when a decision on charges would be made, but it is believed Crown Law solicitors will make their recommendations within a fortnight.

It will then be up to Police Commissioner Rob Robinson and his investigation team as to whether they lay charges.

Options include charging some or all of the men, calling for more information to be collected, or deciding not to pursue charges.

Mrs Nicholas said while she was nervous about the police's decision, she wanted any potential legal processes to start as soon as possible.

The wait during the past year had been excruciating, but she understood the need for police to be meticulous in their investigation and ensure any case was watertight.

"For us it's not a matter of if, it's a matter of when, but when has taken a hell of a long time to get here. It's bloody frustrating," she said.

Operation Austin, led by Dunedin-based officer Superintendent Nick Perry, started as soon as the allegations surfaced.

A team of about 20 detectives, the size of a full-blown murder inquiry team, completed the bulk of their work investigating Mrs Nicholas' rape claims just before Christmas and forwarded preliminary findings to Crown Law solicitors then.

Police gave their first insight into the scope of the operation yesterday, releasing figures showing that more than 2000 people had been interviewed in New Zealand and overseas, with staff clocking up 32,456 hours by the end of September.

A commission of inquiry into police conduct, announced by Prime Minister Helen Clark four days after Mrs Nicholas' and, subsequently, Kaitaia woman Judith Garrett's allegations of police rape, now depends on the outcome of the police investigation.

The commission was put on hold indefinitely in August and will not proceed till criminal investigations and any subsequent court action are completed, because of fears it could contaminate the criminal process. It will meet again next month to evaluate police progress.