Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Police Rape Allegations - Main Index


Jan - Feb 2005

 



The Dominion Post
February 8 2005

Slap on wrist for bad cops
by Nikki MacDonald

Forty-seven police staff were disciplined last year for misconduct ranging from firearms offences to an improper relationship with a criminal.

Four were sacked for their offences, raising questions about the force's supposed hard line.

In a year when public faith in police took a severe battering after rape allegations involving Auckland's top officer, Police Commissioner Rob Robinson promised a tough approach to misconduct.

"The public expects zero tolerance of any criminal behaviour of the police," he said in March.

But figures out of the commissioner's office, issued to The Dominion Post under the Official Information Act, show that some officers disciplined for serious offences such as assault received only a fine or a black mark on their report card.

Police were unable to give details yesterday of individual cases.

Thirty officers and 17 civilian staff were disciplined last year. The figures exclude staff who resigned before being disciplined.

Three constables were sacked -- for assault on duty, an improper relationship with a criminal and theft. Other offences included inappropriate computer use, disgraceful conduct and firearms offences. Most officers involved were fined or received an adverse report -- a written warning.

The civilian staff were mostly warned, for poor performance or misuse of computers. One was dismissed for accessing police information without authority.

Police headquarters' professional standards boss, Superintendent Graham Emery, said misconduct cases remained static, at about 0.5 per cent of the total staff of 9500.

"It is a very small minority. The public should have a lot of confidence in their police."

Cases of assault on duty were usually minor and provoked, he said. Penalties could differ for the same offence, depending on the circumstances. But he questioned the accuracy of the figures, as an officer charged with assault would not be given an adverse report: serious criminal offences were usually prosecuted through the courts and internally, and the officer would be dismissed.

Police Association president Greg O'Connor said the figures did not show the full picture, as most officers charged in court resigned before being disciplined.

But he defended the force's record in investigating its own. "Anyone who believes that the police somehow cover up is very mistaken. They go after their own with a vengeance."