Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Police Rape Allegations - Index


16-31 March 2005

 




The Dominion Post
March 18 2005

Police pair seek to have case dropped
by Haydon Dewes

A courtroom battle is looming to have charges dropped against two former policemen jointly charged with Assistant Police Commissioner Clint Rickards over alleged historic offences.

And the future of a commission of inquiry into police conduct is in question as a result of the charges, with commissioners Bruce Robertson and Dame Margaret Bazley deciding next week whether it should be disbanded.

Rickards and former police colleagues Brad Shipton and Bob Schollum appeared in court on Wednesday to face charges stemming from allegations by Rotorua woman Louise Nicholas revealed in The Dominion Post last January. Their charge details are suppressed.

Lawyers for Shipton and Schollum have indicated they will seek a permanent stay of proceedings to prevent a criminal trial.

Tauranga lawyer Paul Mabey QC, acting for Schollum, has made it clear he does not think the three men would get a fair trial after the amount of publicity the alleged offences had received.

"A stay of proceeding is being contemplated but pre-trial publicity is only one of a number of factors relevant to that application."

He would not say what these factors were. It is expected a stay application would not be made before a depositions hearing, where a court decides if there is a case to answer.

Shipton's lawyer, Bill Nabney, also confirmed yesterday a stay application was being considered due to the publicity.

Rickards' lawyer, John Haigh QC, would not confirm yesterday whether he too was seeking a stay of proceedings.

All three entered no plea when they appeared in court on Wednesday.

Meanwhile, the future of the commission of inquiry into police conduct -- sparked by Mrs Nicholas' allegations -- is in limbo.

In August, commissioners Justice Bruce Robertson and Dame Margaret Bazley decided it should not proceed till criminal inquiries were completed, in fear of contamination.

A written ruling was released revealing details of a closed chambers meeting in May, in which the need to reassess the commission's role if charges were laid was emphasised.

"If that stage is reached, we will need to consider whether ... because of the inevitable time delays which will realistically be not less than a year, we should be discharged from our task and consideration be given at the end of the trial process to what sort of commission is required to deal with any matters which then require attention," the ruling states.

The inquiry's future would be discussed at an open hearing next Thursday in Wellington, a spokesman said.