Child sex abuse
hysteria and the Ellis case |
|
November 30, 1998 Rape Crisis and the Help
Foundation should not attribute their financial crises solely to government
health agencies and private trusts, as implied in "The Second Rape"
(Metro, Sep 98). Rape Crisis credibility finally
evaporated with the sheer effrontery of the figures, definitions and comments
backing its incest campaign. It got $30,000 from the Minister of Social
Welfare to promote that orgy of misinformation. The Help Foundation also bears
responsibility. It claims to have 60 clients per week at its Mt Eden centre
alone (3,120 annually). Dozens of other sexual abuse agencies claim thousands
more clients. But in 1997, there were just 1,328 prosecutions in all
categories of sexual crime. [Later Note : I did not state the number of
CONVICTIONS for 1997, though. They amounted to a total of about 720
convictions for all types of sexual offence.] These agencies claim special
expertise in sexual abuse matters. Their trauma-focused, victim-role
counselling rests on a belief that recovery is a long, slow process, which
only they as "specialists" can provide. Their methodologies have
been challenged and found wanting. Any relationship between their
counselling and beneficial outcome is at best tenuous. Preferred
interventions are those which are brief, solution-orientated and
professionally administered, proved by controlled studies to be safe and
effective. Medication is often an invaluable adjunct to treatment. Funds providers and the public are
now awake to the gross exaggerations and fatal limitations of these
inefficient, ineffectual and advocacy-driven sexual abuse agencies. Much
would be gained by having genuine victims treated in mainstream medical
facilities by skilled professionals. |