Child sex abuse hysteria and the Ellis case


Focus on People - Hall of Fame

 

The wisdom of Gordon Waugh - Index

 



The Dominion
February 24 1999

Time for review
Letter by Gordon Waugh, Auckland
Cosa liaison officer  (Abridged)

Your article Critic of false sex-abuse claims to step down (Feb 2) could mislead those in the sex-abuse industry into a false sense of security. Casualties of Sexual Allegations is not "in danger of folding".

Felicity Goodyear-Smith's work in Cosa has been instrumental in drawing attention to sex-abuse counselling malpractice and has brought about a much needed sense of reality and healthy scepticism. That she is not standing for re-election as president does not signal the closure of Cosa. Her imminent departure provides a natural organisational review point

 

 

 

The Dominion
February 2 1999

Critic of false sex-abuse claims to step down

A group set up to protect people falsely accused of sexual abuse is in danger of folding, with its founder saying her work is done.

The president of Casualties of Sexual Allegations, Felicity Goodyear-Smith, said yesterday that she had decided not to seek re-election in the organisation she started about five years ago.

"I feel I have achieved what I wanted to. The impetus that got the organisation going was the large number of recovered memory-type cases that emerged about 1994.

"It is a problem that, to a large extent, has now been resolved."

Counsellors, doctors and psychiatrists were now much more sceptical about using such methods in sexual abuse cases, she said.

"Clearly, there are still cases of false allegations coming through but much fewer than there used to be."

Dr Goodyear-Smith said two members of the five-strong executive committee had also decided not to seek re-election and the others were considering their options before the organisation's annual meeting in July.

"It's early days in terms of knowing what's happening with the organisation.

"One of the options is to still have local groups offering local support and disband the national organisation."

When first set up, the organisation attracted a membership of about 350, two-thirds of whom were directly involved with false allegations.

Dr Goodyear-Smith, having been involved in the establishment of the HELP foundation for sexual abuse victims in the 1980s and often working with police examining victims, felt the pendulum had swung too far in the complainant's favour.

Ironically, she was married to John Potter, son of Centrepoint founder Bert Potter, who was serving a nine-year prison sentence for perjury, child sex and drugs charges.

Dr Goodyear-Smith said she had no regrets about quitting Cosa.

"It's been an unpaid position and a very big commitment.

"There are still a lot of people out there who need support but we're not the only ones out there to help and that's a positive thing."