Child sex abuse hysteria and the Ellis case


Focus on People - Hall of Fame

 

The wisdom of Gordon Waugh - Index

 



Sunday Star Times
June 11 2000

Medical checks
Letter by Gordon Waugh, Auckland

Sandra Coney is now bewailing the effects of the Dr Morgan Fahey case. She insists on confusing evidence with belief. Her brand of thinking is quite tiresome.

Her dismissal of chaperones completely ignores the ways of the world. With a mandatory chaperone present, she says "during intimate often embarrassing procedures, women have to put up with the audience of a stranger". If that is objectionable, women would never go to specialists.

The formidable power of righteousness - commendable only sometimes - demands checks and balances of equal power. She says the concept of the chaperone "implies distrust". Of course it does. Doctors also need protection from patients who might - and do - make false allegations.

The very few women who feel unsafe with a particular doctor have a range of options. For heaven's sake, take their own chaperone. Trust the professionalism of the practice nurse. Go to another doctor. Go only to female doctors.

I seriously doubt the medical profession has "a culture of tolerance towards abusers". That Fahey pleaded guilty does not mean every GP is likely to "abuse patients" or has "rape on his mind".