Allegations of Sexual Abuse

False Allegations

John Edgar case



Waikato Times
April 23 1998

Edgar takes stand to deny allegations of indecency
by Gordon Jon Thompson

Former Hamilton teacher John Timothy Edgar looked the jury in the eye and told them he did not do it.

Edgar spent nearly four hours denying every allegation of indecency made against him by the Crown in the Hamilton District Court yesterday.

Edgar, 38, is accused of seven counts of indecent assault and one of committing an indecent act. His trial is being heard before Judge Lynton Laing.

For the first time since he was arrested last November, he told his story.

The court had heard testimony from seven boys, via closed-circuit television, that Edgar had touched their genitals while he was a teacher at Hukanui Primary School.

Edgar, who sipped water throughout his testimony, said that while he used the term gay to describe his sexual orientation, he was "presently seeing one of the Hukanui mothers".

He said some children had not been pleasant about his sexual orientation, though he had never been accused of any other inappropriate behaviour.

Edgar denied some of the incidents ever happened and gave a completely different version of others.

He said he often gave lollies to students as a reward for good work.

One of the boys said Edgar gave him 10 lollies to change into a pair of togs last November. While he was changing Edgar allegedly told him to take his underwear off and then indecently assaulted him.

Edgar yesterday said he told the boy to sort out some lost property and then left the boy alone in the classroom. When he came back the boy was changing into a pair of shorts or togs.

He said he was angry the boy might have been stealing the togs and told him to get changed back into his clothes and leave. The boy asked for lollies and Edgar told him to take some.

Even under cross-examination from Crown Prosecutor David Wilson, QC, Edgar remained calm.

Mr Wilson asked Edgar why he had given lollies to the boy when he was angry with him. Edgar said he told the boy to take some lollies because he felt uncomfortable with the situation and wanted to leave the room as quickly as possible.

Edgar was the first witness called by defence counsel Roger Laybourn. He plans to call up to 18 more.