Allegations of Sexual Abuse

False Allegations

John Edgar case



The Dominion
April 30 1998

More male teachers needed - NZEI
NZPA

More males should be recruited into primary school teaching, despite warnings from a former Hamilton teacher cleared of sex offences, the primary teachers' union says.

John Timothy Edgar, 38, warned men yesterday against entering the profession, as most allegations of sexual misconduct "seem to focus on men".

Dr Edgar suggested one solution might be for men to team-teach, meaning they were not left alone in a classroom and so had a legal safeguard.

But New Zealand Educational Institute president Liz Patara said she was a "100 per cent supporter" of recruiting more male teachers and that the issues needed to be kept in perspective.

"All teachers -- not just men -- are vulnerable to allegations of misconduct, particularly when dealing with younger students," Ms Patara said.

"Primary teachers in particular, because of their nurturing and caring role, have to be very careful about their behaviour with students to ensure that their actions are not misconstrued."

Ms Patara said the NZEI had in 1993 developed a code of practice for physical contact with students.

Among other things, the code recommended that teachers, for their own protection and as much as common sense allowed, should avoid physical contact and being alone with students.

"Men should not feel discouraged from becoming teachers --misconduct allegations remain a rare occurrence," she said.

Tai Tokerau Principals Association president Geoff Skudder said male teachers had to be careful that anything they did was not misconstrued, Mr Skudder said.

With an increasing number of solo parent homes in the community, sometimes children wanted reassurance and would seek out someone to give them a hug.

Mr Skudder said he believed men played an important role in primary teaching and was concerned Dr Edgar's comments would discourage them from entering the profession.

He said male teachers were scarce enough as it was, with some schools having none. Yet for some children, male teachers were the only men in their lives.

Dr Edgar's comments had come at a time when interest among young men in teaching appeared to be increasing, as pay rates went up and some other occupations became harder to enter, he said.

--------------------

CAPTION: Waikato Times - Dr Edgar speaks to reporters after being cleared of sexual misconduct charges