Allegations of abuse by NZ Police

peterellis homepage / police allegations / Louise Nicholas vs John Dewar

John Dewar - 2007 - Page 1

 





Waikato Times
July 27 2007

Ex-cop recalls talk of baton
Reon Suddaby

A retired police officer said yesterday he recalled reference to a baton during an interview with Louise Nicholas about an alleged sexual attack.

But he said the notebook he used during the interview disappeared shortly after discussing the allegations with John Dewar, the former senior police officer who is accused of covering up for former colleagues.

On the third day of the trial of former Rotorua CIB head Dewar, retired police Inspector Ray Sutton said he was unable to find his book when asked to produce it five months later.

Yesterday the jury in the High Court at Hamilton was told the notebook detailed Mrs Nicholas' accusations of rape against Clint Rickards, Bob Schollum and Brad Shipton.

Dewar, 55, has denied four counts of attempting to obstruct or defeat the course of justice between 1993 and 1995 in relation to Mrs Nicholas' allegations of sex offences against her by the three police officers in the 1980s.

The Crown claims Dewar refused to take a statement from Mrs Nicholas detailing her allegations against Mr Rickards, Shipton and Schollum, gave inadmissable evidence during two rape trials of another former police officer accused by Mrs Nicholas, and convinced Mrs Nicholas to sign a statement designed to exonerate him from blame in the investigation following the two aborted trials.

After the two mistrials the former police officer was acquitted in a third trial and given permanent name suppression.

Mr Sutton told the court that in January, 1993, Mrs Nicholas' father asked him to meet his daughter to hear allegations of sexual abuse by police.

"Louise related a series of events that she said had occurred at Murupara and Rotorua involving police officers and ex-police officers," Mr Sutton said.

"The thing that I do recall is her reference to a police baton being used during one of those incidents."

Mr Sutton said he wrote down the names of the men Mrs Nicholas said had raped her -- Rickards, Shipton and Schollum. However, when he was asked to produce his notebook five months later, he could not.

The last time he could remember seeing the notebook was when he was briefing Dewar on the allegations in a police office. Mr Sutton said Dewar's request to take over the investigation into Mrs Nicholas' allegations was appropriate, as he was head of CIB.

Mrs Nicholas' mother Barbara Crawford recounted her daughter telling Mr Sutton of the alleged abuse by Mr Rickards, Schollum and Shipton.

"I just remember it was sexual abuse, but when the name Schollum came up, I went into shock; I didn't really hear much of the rest of it," she said.

Earlier Mrs Nicholas fended off accusations from Dewar's lawyer, Paul Mabey QC, that she was an attention-seeker.

"You've been courting and pursuing publicity at every opportunity," he said.

Mrs Nicholas said she did not enjoy the media spotlight.

The trial continues.