Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Mt Maunganui Pack Rape Case


2. Trial Week 1  June 2005

 



Dominion Post
June 21 2005

Woman tells of seaside pack-rape

A woman who won a bet for a date with a man she was interested in was lured to a secluded spot where she was pack-raped, a Wellington jury has been told.

The woman said she was expecting a casual, lighthearted lunch at a cafe but the middle-man who arranged the date drove her to a seaside hut. Four men were waiting inside and the middle-man followed her in.

"I got a hell of a shock," she said giving evidence in the High Court yesterday.

Four men, now aged 40, 46, 47, and 53, have admitted having sex with her at Mt Maunganui in January 1989 but say the woman, who was 20 at the time, was willing. The fifth man has not been identified, prosecutor Brent Stanaway told the jury.

Justice Ron Young has continued extensive suppression orders including the names and occupations of the four men, whose trial is expected to take at least two weeks.

Each faced charges of detaining the woman without her consent with intent to have sex with her and raping her.

One of the men faces an extra charge of rape and two charges of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection. Another man is alleged to have been a party to one of the violations, so also faces that charge and another of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection.

The men pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Mr Stanaway said she was raped and subjected to various indecencies on a stained old mattress on the floor.

The next day, two of the men visited her and behaved as if nothing had happened. It was made clear to the woman in later visits from one of the men that there was little point complaining because it would be her word against that of the five men.

She considered going to the police but thought her complaint would not be taken seriously because she had asked for the meeting with one of the men, Mr Stanaway said.

A police investigation began last year.

The woman told the court she had thought the man very attractive and friendly, and believed the attraction was mutual. She continues giving evidence today.

Defence lawyers Paul Mabey, QC, Bill Nabney, Tony Balme and Rachael Adams said the accused maintained that the woman consented.

Mr Balme said his client talked about the incident at the time, and when police questioned him last year he gave a 78-page written statement.

The woman would give a distorted, twisted version of events that would be exposed as lies, he said.

Ms Adams said her client gave a statement saying he did not witness what happened with the other men but he believed the woman consented to sex with him.