Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Mt Maunganui Pack Rape Case


2. Trial Week 1  June 2005

 



Stuff
June 22 2005

Accused claims he had sex with victim after alleged pack-rape
NZPA

One of four men accused of a pack-rape at Mount Maunganui 16 years ago will testify he had sex with the then 20-year-old woman after the alleged attack, Wellington High Court heard today.

The woman has told the court the man visited her at work and at the motel she was staying in over the summer of January 1989 twice after the alleged rape.

The woman, who was working for a Hamilton-based company in the Bay of Plenty for six weeks over the 1988/89 New Year period, has said the man's intimidatory tactics prevented her from going to police and reporting the incident.

Under cross examination by the man's lawyer, Bill Nabney, the woman denied his client had visited her because she had called him and asked him to.

"I never called him," she told the court.

The man would later testify that he had consensual sex with the woman at the motel, Mr Nabney said.

"That would be an outright lie," she said.

The woman has admitted writing her hometown address and phone number in the man's notebook, but said she gave him her details before the alleged attack.

Mr Nabney suggested she had written in the notebook after the man visited her motel.

"That's a lie," she repeated.

The woman alleges she was raped by five men in January 1989 in an empty building she had been lured to on the false pretence of a lunch date with the man after they developed what she considered a mutual attraction.

The man and three others are now accused of rape after the woman, who now lives in Australia, laid a complaint with police in April 2004.

The fifth man has never been identified or charged.

The men, who are also charged with abduction, admit having sex with the woman but say it was consensual and deny she was restrained.

Court suppression orders prevent identification of the men or their past and present occupation.

The woman alleges over a period of an hour-and-a-half she was restrained, raped, forced to perform oral sex and brutally violated by one man with his fingers and another with a large object. Details of that object are also suppressed.

Now 37-years-old and married with three children, the woman broke down yesterday as she recounted the incident 16 years later.

Under cross examination the woman has continually maintained she did not consent to group sex with the men. She often asked defence lawyers to clarify or repeat questions; asking one to introduce himself to her.

"You know who I am," she told him.

The trial before Justice Ronald Young and the jury of four men and eight women is expected to take up to three weeks.