Peter Ellis web site - Christchurch crèche case


ACC Compensation for Sex Abuse - Index

 

2002 Index 

 




The Dominion
January 10, 2002

ACC 'wastes money' on sex victim campaign
by David McLoughlin

ACC has sent 2000 doctors and other treatment providers 100 cards each with an 0800 number to give to patients who might want to claim compensation for sexual abuse.

 

Wellington occupational health clinic nurse Jenny Graham says the cards are just as much soliciting for business as fliers being distributed around New Zealand by a Christchurch law firm offering to get abuse victims big sums from ACC in return for a commission.

 

Mrs Graham said she was furious when the cards arrived from ACC along with a small stuffed bear just before Christmas. Her husband, a doctor, also received the cards and a bear.

 

"What a waste of money," said Mrs Graham, who is in charge of the Wellington Newspapers occupational health clinic. "I was so angry I was planning to send them back. We look after 500 people and sending us 100 cards suggests they believe one in five of our staff have been abused. ACC is soliciting for people just as much as that law firm."

 

ACC sensitive claims manager Gail Kettle criticised law firm Wakefield Associates this week for its flier offering to get up to $175,000 compensation for sex abuse victims for a commission.

 

She said victims should contact ACC or an approved counsellor, who would deal with their claims without charging.

 

ACC pays for the counselling of sex abuse victims and pays them an "independence allowance" ranging from $10 to $61 a week, paid quarterly.

 

From April 1, accident victims and sex abuse victims will again be able to claim lump sums, abolished in 1992. They will replace the independence allowance and be worth a maximum $100,000 on a sliding scale.

 

Sex abuse victims will be entitled to lump sums without having to complain to police or name an abuser. Counsellors will make recommendations on whether to accept a claim.

 

Ms Kettle defended the cards and bears yesterday. She said it was a joint initiative with Women's Refuges. "It is to make people aware of what is available. It's very easy to become cynical, but there are a lot of genuine people out there who we need to give as much help as possible."

 

There are 900 ACC-approved sex abuse counsellors. Ms Kettle said all were being extensively re-evaluated to make sure they met the standards required when the new act took effect.

 

She said measures were being considered to stop the practice of some counsellors treating victims, sometimes for years, with no apparent benefit to the victim. If there was no improvement after, say, 10 sessions, an independent psychiatrist's assessment would be sought.

 

ACC's lawyer, Gerard McGreevy, said yesterday that Ms Kettle's confirmation in yesterday's Dominion that victims would be able to get lump sums for abuse that happened years ago was wrong.

 

Victims claiming for old incidents after April 1 would continue to be entitled to the independence allowance and other existing entitlements. This was the same as for people injured in accidents before April 1.

 

Victoria University criminologist Willem de Lint said yesterday that resumption of lump sums for sex abuse would lead to a blowout in ACC costs like one that led to lump sums being abolished. Claims rose from 221 in 1988 to 13,000 in 1993. Most claimants then were automatically given $10,000 with no proof required.

 

A victim contacted The Dominion yesterday, saying it was unfair that lump sums would go only to people who claimed after April 1.

 

She said she was abused when she was 11 and 14, and now at 40 she had begun counselling. Her independence allowance was $180 a quarter, and she had to pay $20 toward each counselling session, which came to $240 a quarter. "I'm thinking of giving up counselling as it is costing me more than they give me."