Peter Ellis web site - Christchurch crèche case


ACC Compensation for Sex Abuse - Index

 

2005 Index 

 



NZ Parliament
Questions for Written Answer
Published April 6 2005

Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC



 



3513 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

How many applications have been received by ACC for sexual abuse year by year for the last 4 years, how many of these claims were subsequently withdrawn, how many were approved and how many declined?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the Member to the attached table which provides a breakdown of the number of sensitive claims lodged, accepted, held and declined for the past 4 years. ACC does not collect data on claims that are withdrawn.

Number of Claims Lodged, Accepted, Held and Declined

for Sensitive Claims from 1 July 2000

Financial period ending in June

Lodged

Accepted

Held

Declined

2001

5686

5361

0

287

2002

6703

6166

0

492

2003

6072

4572

0

1406

2004

5726

3816

6

1633

2005 (12 March 2005)

4143

1998

924

1001





 



3514 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

How many lump sum payments have been made under the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Compensation Act 2001, broken down by date of payment, and category of claim?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the member to the attached table. I understand the Member to mean "diagnosis of injury" when she asks for "category of claim".

Lump sum payments are made to claimants who meet strict legislative requirements under the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Compensation Act 2001. A claimant must be assessed as having a whole person impairment over the threshold of 10%, as measured by American Medical Association guidelines.

Lump Sum Payments (made under the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2001)

 

Year

 

 

2003

2004

2005

Total

Amputation/Enucleation

24

41

39

104

Burns (Burn, Corrosive Injury, Scald)

1

8

9

18

Concussion/Brain Injury

 

9

14

23

Deafness

 

1

3

4

Foreign Body in Orifice/Eye

 

12

1

13

Fracture/Dislocation

18

146

171

335

Gradual Onset (not disease/Infection)

 

3

13

16

Infected / Non-infected Laceration, Puncture Wound, Sting

17

60

62

139

Mental Injury / Nervous Shock

 

1

15

16

Occupational Disease/ Infection

 

2

5

7

Other

7

89

117

213

Soft Tissue Injury (Contusion, Internal Organ, Strain)

12

78

125

215

Grand Total

79

450

574

1103





 



3515 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

What is the breakdown of payments to Wakefield Associates for their clients, in the year to June 1 2004 and the year to date broken down by category – whether independent allowance or lump sum, and whether the claims are sensitive claims or not?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the Member to the attached tables showing a breakdown of payments to Wakefield Associates for sensitive claims and non-sensitive claims, since 2 June 2003. The ‘other’ category includes backdated attendant care and backdated weekly compensation payments. If ACC receives new or relevant medical information that was not available at the time of the decision, it may result in a backdated payment to the claimant. The ‘other’ category also includes review costs awarded by the reviewer, which are associated with the claim cost to ACC. The Corporation cannot make the distinction between how much of the amounts paid to Wakefield Associates is subsequently paid out to the claimant and how much is kept by Wakefield Associates. Payments to Wakefield Associates include identified payments made to Accident Compensation Services, who share the same bank account. The Corporation assumes that this is the same company. ACC does not collect information about payments where Wakefield Associates are listed as the claimant’s advocate and payments are made directly to the claimant.

All amounts are exclusive of GST.

Payments to Wakefield Associates for Sensitive Claims

Payment Period

Independence Allowance Payments

Lump Sum Payments

Other

Sensitive Claim Payments Total

Number of Claims

2 June 2003 – 1 June 2004

$1,500,510

$14,000

$47,101

$1,561,611

451

2 June 2004 – 16 March 2005

$496,665

$0

$271,262

$767,927

141



Payments to Wakefield Associates for Non-Sensitive Claims

Payment Period

Independence Allowance Payments

Lump Sum Payments

Other

Non-Sensitive Claim Payments Total

Number of Claims

2 June 2003 – 1 June 2004

$1,185,842

$0

$731,268

$1,917,110

200

2 June 2004- 16 March 2005

$426,700

$13,147

$508,503

$948,350

91





 



3517 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

Has ACC referred any counsellors to their professional body for investigation, if so, what date and why?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the Member to the attached table that sets out the number of counsellors referred to their professional bodies.

ACC places claimant safety as paramount and will refer providers to the Health and Disability Commissioner, and/or the appropriate body in certain circumstances. Reasons for the referrals will include any allegation initiated by an ACC claimant, or staff, where concerns are of a serious nature. ACC does not have the capability or jurisdiction to investigate and determine issues such as competency or misconduct.



Number of Referrals to Professional Bodies for Counsellors.

Year

Number of Referrals

2002

2

2003

1

2004

3

2005

1

 





 



3519 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

What percentage of all people who go onto ACC are still on it after 6 months; after 12 months; after 2 years; after 3 years; and after 5 years?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the Member to the attached table. This information is accurate up to the date 28 February 2005.

It is important to note ACC would usually express this measure as the percentage of people who are rehabilitated under the ACC scheme, within the specified time periods. This rehabilitation rate is based on when the claimants begin receiving weekly compensation payments. Therefore, the Member’s phrase ‘go on ACC’ is taken to mean ‘commence weekly compensation payments’.

Percentage of people remaining on ACC after specified time period

Time period

Percentage remaining on ACC

6 months

14.21 %

12 months

6.68 %

2 years

3.35 %

3 years

1.97 %

5 years

1.82 %





 



3522 (2005). Katherine Rich to the Minister for ACC (15 March 2005):

How many claims initially accepted by ACC have been declined, year by year for the last 5 years and what was the category of claim, and the reason for the claim being declined?


Hon Ruth Dyson (Minister for ACC) replied: (Published 6 April 2005)

I refer the Member to the attached table. The table outlines the claims that were initially accepted by ACC and have had the cover decision changed to declined. This data is provided for the past five years and splits the claims into the different categories of injury. ACC does not collect data on why a claim has been declined. The Corporation does not require this information to allow it to provide entitlements to accepted claims.

For a claim to be accepted by ACC it must meet the provisions of the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation, and Compensation Act 2001. If a claim fails to continue to meet the requirements of the Act, the cover decision will be changed from accepted to declined. A decision to decline cover will have review rights.

Number of claims initially accepted by ACC, where cover decisions have changed to decline (for past 5 years)

 

Financial Year (Ending June)

 

1999/00

2000/01

2001/02

2002/03

2003/04

Total

Fatal

7

4

2

 

 

13

Other Gradual Process

1

 

 

 

 

1

Amputation/Enucleation

1

7

1

11

9

29

Burns (Burn, Corrosive Injury, Scald)

10

19

10

20

37

96

Concussion/Brain Injury

11

16

18

9

19

73

Deafness

57

29

16

11

18

131

Dental Injuries

66

25

17

15

24

147

Foreign Body in Orifice/Eye

24

27

20

32

139

242

Fracture/Dislocation

195

154

134

114

178

775

Gradual Onset (not Disease/Infection)

292

336

179

150

222

1179

Hernia

130

21

4

6

9

170

Infected/Non-infected Laceration, Puncture Wound, Sting

153

184

127

157

455

1076

Inhalation/Ingestion Specific Occasion

5

6

2

1

5

19

Mental Injury/ Nervous Shock

12

6

10

13

95

136

Non-Occupational Disease/Infection

24

15

5

4

4

52

Occupational Disease/Infection

21

32

9

5

11

78

Other

30

68

67

81

122

368

Soft Tissue Injury (Contusion, Internal Organ, Strain)

2150

1585

1183

1108

1706

7732

Toxic/Adverse Effect

1

4

2

1

1

9

Grand Total

3190

2538

1806

1738

3054

12326