Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ


Dr Hiran Fernando (N.P. Doctor) - Index


Index 5.    Trial: Comments

 




Sunday Star Times
October 15 2006

Sex doc's victims say there must be others
by Tony Wall

Two of the women indecently assaulted by disgraced New Plymouth GP Hiran Fernando believe there are other victims yet to come forward and blame the Medical Council for his 20-year spree of abuse.

The Medical Council has admitted it may have put women patients at risk by not suspending Fernando earlier.

The Sunday Star-Times has spoken to the two women, who wrote to the council in 1984 and 1989 outlining their experiences of abuse by the doctor when they were 17 and 18. The council took no action.

It is also under fire for allowing Fernando to continue practising for 18 months after police filed 37 charges of sexual assault.

The women's testimony was accepted by a High Court jury last week which convicted Fernando of 26 counts of indecently assaulting female patients between 1981 and 2002. He is to be sentenced on November 15 and the council has ordered him to stop working.

Medical Council chief executive Philip Pigou told the Taranaki Daily News the council was distressed with Fernando's "appalling offending".

"It's more distressing for the victims and the council apologises for the behaviour of Dr Fernando to the victims," he said.

"In a sentinel event of this nature we would look at our processes to see did we do it well, poorly, or should we have taken different actions."

Pigou said that from June last year Fernando was required to have a chaperone and not undertake intimate examinations except in an emergency. But he conceded women patients who went to Fernando after restrictions were put in place might have been unaware of them because of the court's name suppression.

Safer Centre spokeswoman Lorraine Jans, a New Plymouth sexual abuse counsellor, said the Medical Council was wrong in protecting Fernando and allowing him to continue to practise.

Any other professional body charged with keeping people safe would have suspended that person, she said. One of Fernando's victims told the Star-Times it was ludicrous that he had been allowed to continue working.

"They let me down, and in letting me down they let down who knows how many women? Who knows where it will stop? I put a challenge to all women out there who were abused by him to come forward, even if it's not to lay a formal complaint, so we can know how big this is. I wouldn't be surprised if it was hundreds."

Another victim aged 18 when she was abused, said she knew of two women who had not come forward, as they did not feel strong enough to go through a court case.

The woman said she kept the abuse to herself for five years, fearing no one would believe her, until she finally told her female GP in 1989, who recommended she write to the Medical Council.

After several months of correspondence with the council, she received a letter saying no action would be taken. One of the reasons given was the historical nature of the offending.

"They said if I knew anyone else who had been abused to get them to come forward and maybe they'd do something about it. I was just gutted. I thought, `He's just going to keep on doing this."'

-- additional reporting by Taranaki Daily News