Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2003



The Press
August 5, 2003

Reports may have affected trial


Reports in The Press about the case of Justin Todd Richardson -- charged with making a false complaint of sexual abuse -- may have prejudiced the chances of a fair trial, the defence alleged in the Christchurch District Court.

The claim in a memorandum to the court led Judge Brian Callaghan to sound a warning about publicity on cases before pleas have been entered.

Richardson's defence counsel, Gerald Lascelles, also asked the judge to refer the matter to the Solicitor-General as a possible contempt of court.

He referred to "reported statements of the police to The Press".

"Comments made about this case have raised issues which may have a significant bearing on the conduct of any defence," said Mr Lascelles.

However, Judge Callaghan said he did not wish to refer the matter to the Solicitor-General straight away, because the police and The Press had to be served with the documents and given time to respond.

Richardson, a 34-year-old foundry worker, has not yet entered pleas to charges of making a false complaint, and obtaining a $95,000 "pastoral gesture" from St John of God by a false pretence -- alleging that he had been sexually abused while at Marylands School.

He was yesterday further remanded on bail for 11 days.