Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2005




Waikato Times
June 8 2005

Woman on trial over rape claims
by Jill Rolston

A Cambridge woman laid false complaints of rape and sexual assault against a policeman and his colleague following publicity of historic police rape allegations made by Rotorua woman Louise Nicholas, Hamilton District Court has been told.

The 44-year-old woman –- who has name suppression –- faces two charges of making a false statement to police. Her trial began yesterday.

Crown solicitor Simon Moore said the woman first made an allegation to her lawyer Tim Clarke in early February last year, three days after publicity surrounding Nicholas' case resulted in a high-profile police officer being suspended.

"Given the political climate at the time, these were very topical disclosures to be taken very seriously," Mr Moore said.

The court was told that on April 14 last year the defendant told Hamilton police she had been raped and indecently assaulted by a Waikato constable several times in the previous two months. The woman also falsely claimed she was sexually violated during a search by a female non-sworn police staff member when arrested for credit card and cheque theft on December 9, 2003.

In court yesterday, Judge Robert Spear granted the defendant and the two complainants interim name suppression.

Mr Moore said the defendant's actions were either to obstruct or derail the charges laid against her, or because she was embarrassed at wetting herself at the police station when arrested.

The woman's story changed over time and the alleged dates of the sexual abuse varied.

After an investigation by Counties-Manukau police –- dubbed Operation Castle –- the constable was stood down in June and has since resigned.

The former constable told the court he was called to the station and told he was suspended. He said he had executed a search warrant at the defendant's address and took her to the station for questioning. As the woman wanted to use the toilet, he asked his female colleague to search her as he believed she was hiding something. However, the defendant wet herself before she was searched.

On one of the dates he was accused of sexually assaulting the woman, he was out of town at a wedding, he said.

Under cross-examination by defence lawyer Mike Robb, he admitted seeking counselling before the complaints were laid. He said he had wanted to leave the police force because he did not like the way it had changed him.

His female colleague told the court the defendant stripped after she had wet herself. She found the woman hiding identification cards which were not in her name.