Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2005




The Dominion Post
August 17 2005

Taxi rape claim was false - police
By Chalpat Sonti

A woman who claimed she was raped by a taxi driver then made to pay a $30 fare never actually took a taxi home on the day in question, police say.

They have charged the woman, 23, with making a false rape complaint after they wasted 100 hours investigating it. She will appear in Wellington District Court next week.

The revelation that the complaint was false was met with relief by taxi industry representatives, who say they are worried it is becoming all too easy to smear taxi drivers.

The woman had claimed she was raped in the back of a taxi in Arthur Carman St, Johnsonville, near her home, about 8.30am on August 6. Despite extensive police inquiries, no one on the busy suburban street heard or saw the alleged attack.

Detective Senior Sergeant Shane Cotter said inquiries revealed the woman had not used a taxi that morning. The decision to charge her was not taken lightly, but it was frustrating to have wasted so much time on the inquiry in what was a particularly busy weekend for police.

As well as police time, which could amount to $5000, an after-hours doctor and a counsellor had to be called. The woman underwent a medical examination at a cost of about $1500. However, the cost of the inquiry was not a significant factor in the decision to charge the woman, Mr Cotter said.

Laying a charge of making a false rape complaint was rare in Wellington. He could think of only one similar incident in recent years.

Police do not keep separate statistics for false rape complaints, but lay about 450 false-complaint charges nationally each year.

Taxi Federation executive director Tim Reddish said he was "frustrated" by the complaint.

"In the industry, we're disappointed we've been through all the criticism and fear created through this."

Wellington City Cabs manager Arthur Attrill said that "nine out of 10" such complaints against taxi drivers were false.

"They seem to be becoming more and more prevalent. This one created a lot of discussion."

Regency Cabs spokeswoman Jane Coleman said the complaint was a poor reflection on society. "It's quite sad it's so easy to do something like this to poor taxi drivers."

Mr Cotter said police would continue to investigate every rape complaint seriously. "We don't want to discourage people from coming forward for fear of prosecution (if the allegation was found to be untrue). We weigh up everything before laying charges like this."