Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2005




The Dominion Post
August 24 2005

Secret tape made to back rape claim
by Don Kavanagh

A woman who secretly taped a man allegedly admitting he raped her has been described as a "drama queen" and "manipulative" in Palmerston North District Court.

The woman took the stand and told the court that Trevor Ernest Connolly, 47, a joiner, had made her life hell after the pair split up, coming around to her house and demanding sex before he would leave.

The Crown case is that Connolly raped her on March 9, 2003. The woman told the jury of seven women and five men that on that day Connolly came to her house to talk about their relationship and later pushed her on to a bed and raped her.

The woman said she did not make a formal complaint to police till July 2004 because she had no faith in the police.

The court was played a tape the woman made of a conversation with Connolly as they sat in a car parked at a supermarket. She had made the recording on her lawyer's advice and it included Connolly acknowledging that what he had done was wrong and he apologised.

Connolly's lawyer, Mike Antunovic, said the complainant was making up her testimony "as we go along". He questioned why she had not reported Connolly to police when he was demanding sex from her. She replied that she did not trust the police, but admitted she had called them about alleged thefts from her property.

Mr Antunovic dissected her statement to police, pointing out several discrepancies between that and an affidavit she swore in April 2003, including how the rape happened. The woman became distressed several times during cross-examination, frequently lapsing into tears.

Mr Antunovic again said that the alleged rape was a pack of lies, when the complainant was unable to explain the discrepancies. "You are a drama queen and that's what happens to you, isn't it? Things get out of control," he said. "You are a very manipulative person."

The case is proceeding.