Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2006




Manawatu Standard
June 13 2006

Net date brings rape charge
by Michael Cummings

A woman who was "looking for a bed buddy" on the internet instead found a man now accused in the Palmerston North District Court of raping her.

The 27-year-old woman met the Wellington man on NZDating.com at the beginning of June last year.

They arranged to meet on June 9 at her Palmerston North home but the date resulted in an accusation of rape and the man's appearance in front of a jury yesterday.

Wearing black trousers, a black woollen jumper and a gold wedding band, the man pleaded not guilty to one count of rape and another of sexual violation.

The man's name and occupation are suppressed. A formal application by the Manawatu Standard to have the suppression order lifted was declined by Judge Nevin Dawson.

In his opening address, Crown prosecutor Andru Isac told the jury the accused drove from Wellington to Palmerston North to meet the woman at her home.

"On the way up the accused sent a text message to a third party," he said, saying he was heading to Palmerston North to "sus out" a sexual encounter.

The pair spent time getting to know each other, the accused was introduced to the woman's sister and flatmate, before retiring to her bedroom.

"Things started reasonably innocuously, reasonably innocently, but got rapidly out of control."

The accused forced himself on the woman but she spurned his advances, Mr Isac said.

Undeterred, he allegedly violated the woman before pulling her on top of him and raping her.

"This is a rather disturbing case of a woman being subjected to the prolonged, forceful and predatory intentions of the accused. He simply wouldn't take no for an answer."

The accused left soon after, telling the woman he wasn't going to see her again, Mr Isac said.

But soon after he left, the accused sent her a text message that read: "I feel bad, sorry for raping you."

In another message he said: "I'll understand if you don't want anything to do with me."

"They are a confession by the accused of the sexual assault and the fact he knew exactly what he'd done," Mr Isac said.

In a brief opening statement, the accused's lawyer Val Nisbet urged the jury not to make up its mind before it had heard all the evidence.

He dismissed Mr Isac's portrayal of the complainant as a shy, reserved woman who was preyed upon by the accused.

"She was neither shy or afraid. There was mutual foreplay, there was mutual sex and when she wanted it to stop, it stopped."

Mr Nisbet reminded the jury the woman claims she was straddling the accused throughout the incident.

The woman was the first witness to give evidence yesterday afternoon.

She said the man emailed her after reading her profile on the internet dating site.

Her profile said she was "looking for a bed buddy" but she told the court she just wanted "a male friend to hang out with, to chat with".

The woman looked at his profile before replying.

The two chatted on line and exchanged email and text messages over the next few days.

"He asked if I wanted to meet up with him and I said maybe. I'm not one to meet strangers straight away, I'm too scared."

The man made suggestive comments but she told the court she made it clear she just wanted "a chat and a coffee".

She said she got cold feet the day of the meeting and tried to put it off. But the man persisted and she gave in, she said.

"I got the impression he wanted more than a chat".

(Proceeding)