Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2006




Taranaki Daily News
August 1 2006

Naming unfair
Letter to the Editor
by Bernard Hoult, New Plymouth

A New Plymouth court report (July 29) on the acquittal of a young man on a rape charge seems unfair. The man is named and perhaps shamed; the girl, whose evidence was questionable and, according to the defence lawyer, "extremely emotional when she was drunk", is not named.

 

Unless defence lawyers win suppression for their clients, names are automatically made available and published. It would be a dangerous trend if newspapers were to decide on what names to suppress. Nor can newspapers publish the names of alleged victims, irrespective of the evidence or trial result. EDITOR