Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ


False Allegations - Index


Opinion and Comment - 2005




Sunday Star Times
September 4 2005

Cabbies warned over false rape claims
by Emily Watt

The taxi industry wants drivers to install tape recorders or cameras in their cars to protect themselves after a spate of false rape allegations.

Drivers concede that assaults by cabbies do happen, but say many more false allegations are made or threatened against drivers every day.

Last month, a 23-year-old woman was charged with falsely alleging that she was raped in the back of a Wellington taxi.

And in June, 29-year-old taxi driver Allen Lepou-Umaga, also of Wellington, was found not guilty of raping a 17-year-old nearly a year after the allegation was made.

Richard Wright, head of Wellington's Taxi School, said false allegations and threats to taxi drivers were common.

He condemned any driver who assaulted a passenger, but said drivers also needed to protect themselves against false complaints.

Wright said he once had a woman demand a free ride or threaten to tell police he had molested her.

He kept the radio channel open so others could hear their discussion and drove her towards the police station. She fled.

Wright recommends drivers attach cheap pocket tape recorders to their steering wheel to record any inappropriate conversations.

He also advises his students to eject at a safe location any woman who is misbehaving.

"I tell (students) quite bluntly, if you think the person is going to cause trouble, terminate the fare and drop them off somewhere safe. Better to lose the fare than face false allegations."

Taxi Federation head Tim Reddish said more drivers were installing cameras in their cars to protect drivers and passengers. The cameras were mandatory in some Australian states, and between 5% and 10% of New Zealand taxis had them.

Reddish advised all drivers to seat women passengers in the back seat.

But drivers remained vulnerable to false complaints and he said drivers might follow American trends and install screens between the front and back seats to protect driver and passenger.

"It would be sad if it gets to that," he said.

False assault allegations were hugely damaging to the industry's reputation. "I think most of the serious operators in the business are very concerned about this."

Lawyer Greg King, who recently represented two taxi drivers acquitted of rape charges, said taxi drivers were extremely vulnerable.

King said Lepou-Umaga was unable to work for a year after the rape charge.

Even after being acquitted, he was unable to return to work because his reputation was sullied.

King said the media should be more balanced in reporting such events and there should be harsher penalties for those who make false complaints.