Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


St John of God - Marylands - Index


2006/2 - Moloney & Garchow; Federal Court Appeal

 




The Press
April 29 2006

Alleged abuse victims join extradition call
by Yvonne Martin

Alleged victims of two Catholic clergymen facing historic sexual-abuse charges are joining calls for them to be extradited to New Zealand.

Two St John of God Order members, Brother Rodger Moloney, 71, and Father Raymond Garchow, 58, have been fighting extradition from Sydney since their arrest in December 2003.

Last week, an Australian Federal Court judge overturned an extradition order against the men on the grounds they could not get a fair trial in New Zealand.

Crown solicitors in Christchurch have reviewed the judgment and made a recommendation to the Crown Law Office on the prospects of an appeal.

The Solicitor-General will make a decision in the next few days. Any appeal has to be lodged by May 5.

Moloney faces 28 charges of abusing 12 boys while he was a teacher and prior at Marylands School in Halswell, Christchurch, in the 1970s.

Garchow faces four charges relating to alleged events at the same residential school for intellectually impaired boys.

Alleged victims have told The Weekend Press that the men should be forced to return and face charges.

"I think they should face what has happened," said one.

"The reason I came forward is that I would hate it to happen to my children. I don't want it to happen to anyone else."

He said the church paying the clergymen's legal bills so far made a "mockery" of the situation.

The order's Australasian head, Brother Peter Burke, has ruled out paying the men's fees beyond the Federal Court hearing.

Another alleged victim said the long delay in justice was an outrage.

"It should never have taken this long," he said.

"It's sending the wrong message to people. They (Moloney and Garchow) should be made to come back to New Zealand and face charges."

Another former brother, Bernard McGrath, 58, was sentenced to five years jail this week for sexually abusing boys at Marylands in the 1970s.

A jury found him guilty this month on 21 counts of sexual offending against children from 1974 to 1977.

Name suppression was lifted for Moloney this week, but details of allegations against the Australian pair that emerged during the McGrath trial remain suppressed.