Allegations of Sexual Abuse

False Allegations

Michael Neville case



NZ Herald
December 3 2004

Teacher defeats sex counts
NZPA

The case of a teacher cleared of sex charges against young pupils highlights an "occupational hazard" facing males in particular, says the primary teachers union.

A packed public gallery erupted in cheers, tears and high-fives yesterday as Michael Warren Neville walked from the Palmerston North District Court a free man.

It took the jury of 10 women and two men 12 hours to reach verdicts over the charges against Mr Neville, after being sent out by Judge Les Atkins about 3.15pm on Wednesday.

"When the first [not guilty verdict] came in, I thought there's no way the others could have come out as a guilty verdict," said the accused's brother, Terry Neville.

"Justice prevailed."

Michael Neville, aged 48 - who at one time held a senior position at the Kapiti-area school where the offences were alleged to have occurred - faced four counts of indecent assaults on girls under 12. The charges covered the period from January 1999 to August last year.

The name of the school remains suppressed.

Welcoming the verdict, the New Zealand Educational Institute - the primary school teachers union - said the case showed the vulnerability of teachers. "It highlights an occupational hazard, faced in particular by male teachers," said national secretary Lynne Bruce.

The NZEI would review the case and consider its implications for union members.

Mr Neville looked stressed and emotional as he stood in the dock for the reading of the verdicts.

Collective sighs of relief ran through the court as not-guilty verdicts rolled in one after the other.

A number of people, and Mr Neville, began weeping.

He said later that the trauma of the eight-day trial and 18 months of stress in the leadup to it had not diminished his love of teaching.

"I still love the profession, even where I work."

He had no comment to make about his accusers, but said he dreamed of returning to teaching.

Mr Neville's lawyers, Bruce Squire, QC, and Sandra Moran, both of Wellington, were given a standing ovation as they left the court, and another round of applause as they drove off.

About 40 of Mr Neville's friends, family and colleagues were celebrating the verdicts at his house in Levin last night, said a member of the school's board.

"Plenty of toasting going on and everyone's hugging and kissing. It's great."