Allegations of Sexual Abuse



False Allegations Index

 

 



The Michael Neville case
A primary school teacher accused of
sexual abuse by pupils.
Found Not Guilty; Police Criticised

News Reports

This page last updated Jan 5 2005


2005-0105 - Newstalk ZB - Abuse case prompts review of advice
NZEI national president Colin Tarr says the school's community is fortunate to have such a dedicated and hard-working teacher. …….. Mr Tarr says the case has raised a number of issues for the teaching profession, and as a result, the NZEI will be looking at the advice it gives its members


2005-0105 - Stuff - Union welcomes teacher's reinstatement
NZPA -
NZEI national president Colin Tarr said the union had supported Mr Neville since the allegations against him were made 19 months ago. "The information the union had from the outset of the case made it clear he was innocent of the charges," Mr Tarr said in a statement. "We welcomed his acquittal and now we welcome the news that he will be returning to the classroom at the school where he has taught since 1995.'

2005-0105 - Dominion Post - Union pleased
Educational Institute president Colin Tarr said the union supported Mr Neville, who fought the charges. "We hope he is allowed to put the events of the last 19 months behind him."

2005-0104 - Dominion Post - Back to school for cleared teacher
by Robyn McLean and NZPA - The school board announced the decision in a newsletter to parents on December 29. "The committee met recently with Mike at which an open and frank discourse took place," it said. "The committee unanimously decided that it was appropriate that [he] be welcomed back to his full teaching duties." Board members and teachers would meet to discuss "ongoing issues", which would include a "full discussion about [the] school's physical contact policy and potential health and safety issues".

2005-0104 - NZEI - NZEI Delighted Acquitted Teacher Has His Job Back
NZEI Press Release - NZEI Te Riu Roa is delighted that Levin school teacher, Mike Neville, has his job back following his acquittal a month ago. “Mike is a member of NZEI Te Riu Roa and the union has supported him throughout his ordeal, which began 19 months ago when accusations were made against him,” says NZEI Te Riu Roa National President, Colin Tarr. “The information the union had from the outset of the case made it clear he was innocent of the charges.”

2004-1218 - Dominion Post - Acquitted teacher gets his job back
by Sophie Neville - The Kapiti teacher acquitted of sex charges involving former pupils has been reinstated at the small rural school where he used to teach…… Mr Neville said he was aware of one family that had left, but the support of the rest of the community had been huge. He was still feeling buoyant about the acquittal. "The community has been amazing. It's been really tremendous. They haven't backed away from us at all."

2004-1211 – Dominion Post - Safe conduct for teachers
by Sophie Neville - The climate of panic around child safety means the sad reality for male teachers is to safeguard themselves against false accusations

2004-1208 – NZ Herald - Tragedy of the teaching profession
Editorial-
Few items of news have been sadder than the plight of Kapiti Coast schoolteacher Mike Neville after his acquittal last week on four charges of indecent assault of pupils. Not much of the case can be discussed since the names of the complainants and the school have been suppressed, but the jury’s verdict speaks for itself.

2004-1207 – NZ Herald - 'Safe practice' casts teachers as abusers
by Alison Jones -
The acquittal of Michael Neville, the schoolteacher accused of abusing his pupils, was welcomed cautiously by the primary teachers' union, the New Zealand Educational Institute. Its national secretary, Lynne Bruce, said not that the case marked a victory but that it highlighted an "occupational hazard" for (particularly male) primary teachers. That is disturbing enough. But what's more alarming is that the policies and practices intended to guard against this risk unintentionally maintain the idea of the teacher as a sexual abuser.



Cartoon: Tom Scott; Dec 6 2004

2004-1206 - Child Forum Research Network - NZEI Still Letting Male Teachers Down
Press Release -
In primary and early childhood education, support for male teachers is at an all time low according to education researcher Dr Sarah Farquhar. NZEI as the union for teachers of young children should be telling teachers to resist the moral panic concerning physical contact with children and it should be playing a leading role in rehabilitating the negative image that surrounds being a male teacher

2004-1206 – NZ Herald - Acquitted teacher will face tough fight back
The primary teachers' union says it will lend its full force to helping a teacher cleared of sexual assault to get back into the classroom - but experts warn he could face a long road ahead.

2004-1204 – Dominion Post - We know Neville did it, police told mum
By Sophie Neville - The mother of a girl who accused a teacher of sexually assaulting her says she was told by police that the man was a paedophile and they knew he was guilty. …..He says he was treated as a criminal by police "from the word go". The officers who arrested him came to his house at 8am in black clothes and black wrap-around sunglasses. They would not let him dress alone, and told his wife: "He's our prisoner, we'll go where we like." "It really was bizarre. Like straight out of a movie," Mr Neville said

2004-1204 – NZ Herald - Acquitted teacher refuses to be bitter, just wants to work
The teacher acquitted this week of four counts of indecently assaulting schoolgirls in his care is adamant he wants to return to the job but the wounds of the past 18 months are raw.  Mr Neville believes he was unfairly treated by police who, he says, assumed his guilt before even speaking with him last year, then ran a six-week publicity campaign to try to draw out more victims.

2004-1203 – The Press - Teachers 'vulnerable'
NZPA -
A teacher acquitted yesterday on sex charges levelled against him by former pupils says he wants to return to the school, almost 1-1/2 years after the case began. Neville said he was "absolutely, unbelievably relieved" at the verdict. "A huge relief after 17 months of hell. It's all over," he said

2004-1203 – One News - Teacher unhappy with police inquiry
Horowhenua teacher Michael Neville, who was acquitted of indecently assaulting four young girls, may take action against the police. Neville's lawyer Bruce Squire QC, said the trial took a huge toll on Neville and aspects of the police inquiry were "less than satisfactory."


2004-1203 – One News - Acquitted teacher considering action
Horowhenua teacher Michael Neville, who was acquitted of indecently assaulting four young girls, may take action against the police. Neville's lawyer Bruce Squire QC, said the trial took a huge toll on Neville and aspects of the police inquiry were "less than satisfactory."


2004-1203 – NZ Herald - Not-guilty teacher considers action against police
NZPA -
A Kapiti teacher yesterday cleared of sexually assaulting girls at his school wants to return to the school but is considering legal action against the police over their investigation

2004-1203 – NZ Herald - Teacher defeats sex counts
The case of a teacher cleared of sex charges against young pupils highlights an "occupational hazard" facing males in particular, says the primary teachers union. A packed public gallery erupted in cheers, tears and high-fives yesterday as Michael Warren Neville walked from the Palmerston North District Court a free man.

2004-1203 – Manawatu Standard - Jury sets Neville free
by David Eames - A packed public gallery erupted in cheers, tears and high fives as former teacher Michael Warren Neville walked from the Palmerston North District Court a free man yesterday. It took the jury of 10 women and two men 12 hours to decide he was not guilty on indecent assault charges.

2004-1203 – Newstalk ZB - Teacher has union support
A Horowhenua teacher acquitted of sex abuse charges has the full support of his union. ……The primary teachers union welcomes the acquittal. NZEI national secretary Lynne Bruce says from the information Mr Neville's legal team provided, the union had formed the view he was innocent.

2004-1203 – Dominion Post - The long road back from hell
By Sophie Neville - Allegations of indecent assault against a Kapiti teacher spread their ripples far beyond the accused, the complainants and their families. Sophie Neville reports on reaction to yesterday's not guilty verdicts.



2004-1203 – Dominion Post - 'A victory for male teachers'
by Mervyn Dykes - Kapiti teacher Michael Neville says his acquittal on indecent assault charges is a great victory for male teachers everywhere. "This is a real breakthrough," he said yesterday, his face streaked with tears. "Male teachers of young children can take new heart from knowing that there is still sense and justice in this world."












Photos:
Relief: Michael Neville and his wife Adele are ecstatic as they leave the court after he received four not guilty verdicts on indecent assault charges.
by Kent Blechynden




2004-1202 – One News - Acquitted man wants to teach again
But supporters are critical of the police investigation. In the middle of last year parents were given an investigation outline by police. It said a sexual assault had taken place, yet at that stage no charges had been laid against Neville. "I think they basically ran a campaign as opposed to an objective, impartial assessment of what was going on," says supporter Ian McIntosh.

2004-1202 - NZEI - NZEI Welcomes Teachers Acquittal
Press Release - NZEI Te Riu Roa has welcomed the acquittal of Levin school teacher, Mike Neville, who is a member of the union. "NZEI Te Riu Roa has supported Mike throughout this case,” says NZEI Te Riu Roa National Secretary, Lynne Bruce. “From the information we had the union formed the view that he was innocent of the charges against him,” says Ms Bruce.

2004-1202 – Newstalk ZB - Teacher ready to go back to classroom
The Horowhenua teacher who has been acquitted of sex abuse charges against four former pupils says he has not been put off the profession. Michael Neville was this afternoon found not guilty at the Palmerston North District Court of indecently assaulting four girls under the age of 12, leaving his family and friends in tears of joy.

2004-1202 – Manawatu Standard – Teacher acquitted of indecent assault charges
A packed public gallery erupted in cheers, tears and high-fives as a schoolteacher cleared of sex charges walked from Palmerston North District Court a free man today. …….. "When the first (not guilty verdict) came in, I thought there's no way the others could have come out as a guilty verdict," the accused's brother, Terry Neville, said. "Justice prevailed."


2004-1202 - IRN - Teacher not guilty on abuse charges
Supporters of Michael Neville erupted into cheers in the courtroom after he was found not guilty of indecent assault. A Horowhenua teacher charged with the indecent assault of four former students has been found not guilty on all four charges.

2004-1202 - Newstalk ZB - Teacher not guilty on abuse charges-
A Horowhenua teacher charged with the indecent assault of four former students has been found not guilty on all four charges. A jury at the Palmerston North District Court has just returned with its verdict.

2004-1202 - Manawatu Standard - Sex assault jury back in court today
by David Eames - A Palmerston North District Court jury yesterday went to a hotel room for the night, stuck for a verdict in the case of Horowhenua schoolteacher Michael Warren Neville, accused of indecently assaulting four of his female pupils.

2004-1202 - Dominion Post - Court Packed
Defence lawyer Bruce Squire QC said the Crown's case was based on the uncorroborated evidence of four complainants. The first complainant had said during her evidence that her best friend had witnessed the offence, but the Crown had not called the friend as a witness.

Crown lawyer Ben Vanderkolk accused some of the defence witnesses of a cynical attitude concerning allegations of dishonesty and lying against two of the complainants. Incidents treated lightly at school assumed major importance during the trial.

Judge Atkins told the jury that, to constitute an assault, touching had to be deliberate or intentional. "The second thing to consider is whether the assault was an indecent one and that is for you alone to decide."

2004-1201 - IRN - Sex abuse trial closing arguments
Closing arguments will be heard today in the sex abuse trial of a teacher in the Palmerston North District Court.

2004-1202 - Newstalk ZB – Jurors Revisit
A jury hearing the trial of a Horowhenua school teacher charged with indecent assault will revisit video evidence from one of the complainants this morning………The jury of ten women and two men was out for seven hours before retiring late last night.

2004-1201 - Newstalk ZB - Lawyers sum up in abuse case
The crown and defence teams have summed up their cases in the sex abuse trial of a Horowhenua school teacher……Prosecutor Ben Vanderkolk told the jury that there are coincidences between the evidence presented by the four children and that cannot be ignored…..However, the defence told the court there are serious flaws in the evidence of the complainants. Bruce Squire QC told the jury the evidence of one of girls was not feasible for a start.

2004-1201 – Newstalk ZB - Sex abuse trial closing arguments
Closing arguments will be heard today in the sex abuse trial of a teacher in the Palmerston North District Court.

2004-1201 – Dominion Post - Teacher's trial draws to a close
Closing arguments in the indecent assault trial of Kapiti teacher Michael Warren Neville are to begin this morning and the jury could retire to consider its verdict as early as this afternoon.

2004-1130 – Dominion Post - Teachers challenge complainant's honesty
Witnesses have challenged the honesty of another complainant in the trial of a Kapiti teacher for indecent assault. ….Yesterday, in Palmerston North District Court, three teachers called as defence witnesses said the third girl, who alleged Neville had put his hand inside her underwear and assaulted her, also could not be relied on to tell the truth.

2004-1127 – Dominion Post - Girls not truthful, teacher tells court
Two of the four girls said to have been indecently assaulted by Kapiti teacher Michael Warren Neville could not be relied upon to tell the truth, their former deputy principal told Palmerston North District Court yesterday.

2004-1126 – NZ Herald - Teacher on trial takes the stand
NZPA - A 48-year-old teacher with a penchant for drawing smiley faces and hosting "mat time" for pre-schoolers took the witness box yesterday afternoon to deny allegations he indecently assaulted four of his pupils.

2004-1126 - IRN - Teacher says nothing sexual in pupil interaction
A Horowhenua teacher accused of indecent assault of his pupils says there was never anything sexual about the way he interacted with them……. Neville told the court while he sometimes patted children's backs or shoulders when praising them, or would occasionally hug a student, there was never anything inappropriate. He also told the court he often had parent helpers in his class and parents often popped in.

2004-1126 - IRN - Defence mounts sex abuse case
The defence has mounted its case at the Palmerston North District Court in the sex abuse trial of a Horowhenua schoolteacher…. The defence is calling 16 witnesses. Neville himself has started giving evidence

2004-1126 – Newstalk ZB - Teacher says nothing sexual in pupil interaction
A Horowhenua teacher accused of indecent assault of his pupils says there was never anything sexual about the way he interacted with them.

2004-1126 – Newstalk ZB - Spotlight on credibility
The credibility of two complainants in the sex abuse case against a Horowhenua teacher have come under the spotlight.

2004-1126 – Newstalk ZB - Defence mounts sex abuse case
The defence has mounted its case at the Palmerston North District Court in the sex abuse trial of a Horowhenua schoolteacher.

2004-1126 – Manawatu Standard - Teacher enters the witness box
by David Eames - A 48-year-old schoolteacher with a penchant for drawing smiley faces and hosting "mat time" for pre-schoolers took the witness box yesterday afternoon to deny allegations he indecently assaulted four of his pupils.

2004-1126 – Dominion Post - Kapiti teacher kept in dark about allegations
Former Kapiti teacher Michael Warren Neville was suspended before he knew the nature of the allegations against him, he told Palmerston North District Court yesterday. ……He said the first he knew of any problem was when he was called to a meeting with the principal of his school and the chairman of its board of trustees in June last year.

2004-1125 - IRN - Jury holds teacher's life in its hands
The defence, in opening its case in the sex abuse trial against a Horowhenua teacher, told the jury they hold his life in their hands

2004-1125 – Newstalk ZB - Mum gives evidence in sex abuse case
The mother of one of the complainants in the sex abuse case against a Horowhenua school teacher says her daughter adored him.

2004-1125 – Newstalk ZB - Jury holds teacher's life in its hands
Neville's lawyer told the jury this afternoon in Palmerston North that the allegations border on being ruinous to a man who has committed himself to improving the lot of children. Neville himself has started giving evidence. The 48-year-old talked about how he decided to go to teacher's college after being told he had a natural affinity with children.

2004-1125 – Manawatu Standard - Third complainant tells of touching
by Don Kavanagh - Another girl gave evidence of being indecently assaulted at school as the trial of a Horowhenua schoolteacher continued in Palmerston North District Court yesterday. ….The third complainant, none of whom can be identified, yesterday gave evidence of Neville touching her after she helped him tidy after class.

2004-1125 – Dominion Post - More girls testify against teacher
A girl told the Palmerston North District Court yesterday that former Kapiti teacher Michael Warren Neville put his hand into her pants and touched her indecently. She was the third of four complainants called to give evidence by video after the first girl said the teacher had touched her inappropriately during spelling checks

2004-1124 – Newstalk ZB - Girls give evidence against teacher
Three girls have now given evidence in the case against a Horowhenua primary school teacher accused of indecent assault.

2004-1124 – Manawatu Standard - 12-year-old cross-examined in schoolteacher trial
The first of four alleged victims in the trial of Horowhenua schoolteacher Michael Warren Neville was cross-examined yesterday. Defence counsel Bruce Squire questioned the now 12-year-old girl about finer points of allegations against Neville, as well as trouble she allegedly got into for stealing at school.

2004-1124 – Dominion Post - Girl tells of teacher's abuse
by Mervyn Dykes - A girl who claims her teacher abused her said she avoided wearing skirts because they made it easier for him to touch her. When giving evidence by video, the girl said she chose to wear shorts and pants instead.

2004-1123 – Manawatu Standard - Trial opens for teacher accused of fondling pupils
Kapiti Coast primary school teacher Michael Warren Neville, 48, went on trial yesterday accused of indecently assaulting four of his female pupils over a four-year period.

2004-1123 – Manawatu Standard - Former pupil testifies against teacher
by David Eames - A schoolteacher who allegedly indecently touched a seven-year-old pupil while he took her for a spelling lesson went on trial yesterday accused of indecently assaulting four pupils over a four-year period. Michael Warren Neville - who at one point held a senior position at a Horowhenua school - faces four counts alleging indecent assaults on girls under 12. The charges cover the period from January 1999 to August 2003.

2004-1123 – Dominion Post - Teacher touched girl in class, court told
The trial of a Kapiti schoolteacher facing four charges of indecently assaulting young female pupils has heard videotaped evidence from one complainant that he touched her during spelling tests. The girl was seven years old when the alleged touching took place and she outlined what had happened four years later in a police interview.

2004-1122 – One News - Primary school teacher facing charges
The trial of a primary school teacher accused of indecently assaulting four of his pupils has opened in Palmerston North. Michael Neville, 48, who has taught at the Horowhenua school since 1995, denies indecently assaulting the four girls who were all under the age of 12 at the time of the alleged assaults.

2004-1122 – Newstalk ZB - Indecent charges against teacher
The Crown has opened its case against a Horowhenua teacher charged with indecently assaulting four former pupils

2004-1122 - IRN - Indecent charges against teacher
The Crown has opened its case against a Horowhenua teacher charged with indecently assaulting four former pupils. Michael Neville is accused of touching inappropriately, girls aged between seven and 10 at the time, between 1999 and 2003

2004-1122 - IRN - Teacher in court charged with sex offences
A trial gets underway today for a Horowhenua primary school teacher accused of sexual assault against four former pupils

2004-0311 – Kapiti News - News headlines
Kapiti Coast school-teacher Michael Neville is to face charges of indecently assaulting four pupils in a court trial. In the Palmerston North District Court this week a pre-trial hearing was set down for late May. Neville faces four charges of indecently assaulting girls under the age of twelve during a three-year period

2004-0309 – Dominion Post - Trial date for teacher
Kapiti Coast schoolteacher Michael Warren Neville, who is accused of indecently assaulting four pupils, will stand trial on August 16

2003-1222 – Dominion Post - Sex charges
An NZPA report on the appearance of Kapiti Coast schoolteacher Michael Warren Neville, 47, in Palmerston North District Court on Friday incorrectly stated that the four charges he faces of indecently assaulting girls under 12 over a three-year period were representative. The charges were not representative

2003-1220 – Manawatu Standard - School teacher on sex charges
Justices of the Peace Herb Yates and Robert Campbell ruled Neville had a prima facie case to answer. He was remanded on bail to a district court call-over on February 10.

2003-1219 – Manawatu Standard - Objections punctuate hearing of evidence against teacher
Three complainants' mothers gave evidence at the depositions. One of them told the court she had seen Neville "frequently" hugging girls. She had also seen him cuddling the girls, holding their hands, or putting them on his knee. Another mother called him "friendly, lovely. Kids loved him". "If a child would fall over, he would go and pick him up and give him a bit of a cuddle."

2003-1219 – Dominion Post - Girls sat on teacher's knee, court told
The woman told the two presiding justices of the peace that she was a frequent visitor to the school, which also cannot be named. During 1999, when her daughter was seven, she often saw Neville cuddling girls, holding hands with them and having them sit on his knee. "Not just with my daughter, but with other children," she said. In the playground children would run up to him, hug him and hold his hand, she said. However, the woman said she never challenged Neville about his actions

2003-1106 – NZ Herald - Photographer tackled outside court
Two women supporters of a schoolteacher on sex charges grabbed a photographer as he pursued the accused outside Levin District Court yesterday

2003-1106 – Dominion Post - Date set for hearing on Kapiti teacher
Judge Phillip Connell remanded Neville, 47, on bail for the depositions hearing to be held at Palmerston North District Court on December 18 and 19. As had been the case for his previous appearance, Neville's supporters yesterday made strenuous attempts to shield him from the media -- this time tackling Dominion Post photographer Maarten Holl.

2003-1021 – Dominion Post - Teacher faces fourth sex charge
. Detective Sergeant Peter Govers of Levin police said yesterday that the fourth charge was laid after a call to an 0800 number that police had set up for the case. Mr Govers said the latest girl to complain, also a former pupil of Neville, alleged that he had indecently assaulted her "during class time during the year 2001".

2003-1009 – Manawatu Standard - Teacher named
Name suppression was yesterday lifted on a Levin schoolteacher charged with indecently assaulting three of his pupils. Michael Neville, 47, a teacher of eight years, faces three representative charges covering a three-year period from 1999

2003-1009 – Dominion Post - Teacher facing sexual assault charges named
A primary school teacher charged with indecently assaulting three girls aged under 12 has lost interim name suppression. Police arrested Michael Warren Neville, 47, who lives in Levin but teaches on the Kapiti Coast, on September 23. They charged him with indecently assaulting three girls, all former pupils aged under 12, between January 1999 and August this year