Allegations of Sexual Abuse

False Allegations

Nick Wills



Waikato Times
October 17 1996

Victim critical of police
by Kris McGehan

Nick Wills is no rapist. Everyone knows that -- now.

Yet some of the stigma remains from a harrowing tale of sex, lies and deceit the 22-year-old Waikato University student has endured in the past year.

This week a Police Complaints Authority report vindicated his claims that police should not have charged him with rape last year.

He has also paid off $27,000 in legal bills with a combined compensation deal of $30,000 from the police and his former employer, the Bryant Hall Trust Board.

Mr Wills took the trust board to the Employment Court after he was sacked as deputy warden of the university hostel during the investigation into the rape complaint.

"The most important part of all this has been the very bad handling of the case by the police.

"I know that my accuser was very convincing -- I'm not disputing that. But the fact is that they (the police) didn't do their job properly. I wasn't going to let them get away with it."

In August last year he was arrested for the alleged rape of a fellow student in the hostel.

The woman was later convicted of making a false statement to police. Mr Wills was cleared of charges of rape and threatening to kill.

But the three months he spent under suspicion as a serial rapist can never be compensated for. "It was pure hell. I was in `stunned mullet' mode for most of that time."

He says he had to endure constant suspicion from people: "Everyone would look sideways at me, it was so obvious." Then there were the relentless rumours that he was a serial rapist with a swag of attacks under his belt.

"I soon realised who my real friends were. My true friends stuck by me, but some doubted me. It was a strange and emotional time."

One concern was how his relationship with female friends would be affected.

But they were the ones who remained staunchly by his side.

Mr Wills says he knew his accuser "only vaguely". They lived on the same floor of the hostel and shared some courses.

He stands by his claim police failed to investigate his alibi and he hopes police learn from the experience.

"Let this be a reminder to the police. I hope some good comes out of it."

In his decision, Police Complaints Authority deputy chief Ewen Robertson said there was a "neglect of duty" in the police inquiry.

Police Assistant Commissioner Bruce Scott today said police were often criticised for questioning (rape case) complainants unnecessarily and not believing them. "Here we have a case where a detective actually went the other way and readily accepted what turned out to be a pack of lies."

The detective handling the investigation, Chris Scahill, was unable to be reached today by the Times.

--------------------

CAPTION:  VINDICATION: Waikato law student Nick Wills reflects on the "pure hell" he endured while under investigation for rape. PICTURE: Stephen Barker