Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Mt Maunganui Pack Rape Case


1. Pretrial - From July 2004

 




NZ Herald
July 20 2004

Four face charges over 1989 rape
by Rosaleen MacBrayne

Police investigating the alleged rape of Rotorua woman Louise Nicholas have arrested four men in connection with a separate rape complaint.

The alleged rape took place in Mt Maunganui at New Year in 1989.

Three men appeared in court yesterday, two in Tauranga and one in Napier.

A fourth man is expected to be charged in connection with the case and to appear in the Tauranga District Court today.

The three defendants yesterday were granted interim name suppression and bailed to appear at Tauranga District Court on August 2. They have not pleaded to the charges.

The man who appeared in Napier faced counts of unlawful sexual connection, sexual violation by rape and detaining a person without consent in order to have sexual intercourse, before Judge Tony Adeane.

In Tauranga, one defendant was charged with two counts each of rape and unlawful sexual connection and one of detaining. The other accused each faced a charge of rape and detaining.

Christchurch Crown prosecutor Brent Stanaway appeared for the police.

In a media statement yesterday Deputy Commissioner Steve Long said the three arrests followed "considerable investigations" made by Wellington-based police, who had worked on the case since April of this year.

A police spokesman said the police officers working on the inquiry were the same ones investigating the case of Louise Nicholas, who alleged in January that she was pack-raped and violated with a police baton by three police officers in 1986.

But they said the latest case was entirely separate to any matters involving Ms Nicholas.

The four men were spoken to at their homes yesterday before the afternoon court appearances.

Those in court were given strict bail conditions including residential, non-association and non-contact clauses, and surrendering their passports.

Tauranga Judge Christopher Harding told the pair before him late in the afternoon that one of the reasons he was granting interim name suppression was to give them a reasonable opportunity to advise those close to them, since the charges had just been laid.

The judge warned that suppression was not given lightly. Other factors he took into consideration were the likelihood of some "significant delay" in the matter going to trial and to avoid impeding a fair trial.

"These matters are not entirely disconnected with others of previous publicity," he said.

Rachael Adams, who appeared for the two Tauranga men, said there had "already been quite widespread and dramatic media coverage on parallel but unrelated matters".

Tony Balme, for the fourth man, said his client would also be applying for name suppression and he would not comment further.