Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Mt Maunganui Pack Rape Case


4. Verdict  July 2005

 




The Dominion Post
July 6 2005

Guilty verdicts in pack-rape case

Muffled sobs turned into wailing when a jury found four men guilty of pack-raping a woman in Mt Maunganui 16 years ago.

The men's supporters broke down, despite Justice Ron Young's request for them not to show any reaction while the verdicts were delivered, out of consideration for the jury.

The woman whose complaint in April last year led to the trial was also in the High Court at Wellington, slipping into the back row flanked by police and leaving as soon as the 13 verdicts were read yesterday. A police spokesman said the woman would not comment on the result.

The jury found Peter Mana McNamara, 46, of Mt Maunganui, Warren Graham Hales, 40, of Tauranga, and two men, aged 47 and 53, whose names are still suppressed, guilty of abducting and raping the woman. The men whose names were suppressed were acquitted of sexually violating the woman with an object, but both were convicted of separate sexual violation charges and the 47-year-old was convicted of an extra rape charge. Key details in the case remain suppressed, but Justice Young refused to continue suppression of the names of McNamara and Hales.

All four are in custody pending sentencing on August 5. Unlike their supporters they did little more than shake heads to show they disagreed with the verdicts.

The woman, now 37, had told the jury she had fancied one of the men and through a go-between had arranged what she thought was lunch with him in January 1989. Instead she was lured to a hut where her hands were bound and she was raped and subjected to other indecencies.

The men said it was she who had suggested sex and had been a willing partner. It was denied she had been restrained or that an object was used during the incident.

The jury of eight women and four men had begun considering its verdicts at noon on Monday and returned with a result a few minutes before noon yesterday. The trial began on June 20.

The woman now lives in Australia.