www.peterellis.co.nz : seeking justice for Peter Ellis : mail to: [email protected]

Accusations of Abuse in Institutions

 

Index: Home Page Peter Ellis
Index: Accusations in Institutions

<<< earlier    News Reports Jan-Mar 2004    later >>>

 


2004-0316 - The Press - Reappointed
Brother Peter Burke, the Australasian head of the St John of God Order, has been re-elected for another three-year term. He is best known in New Zealand as frontman for the Catholic order in its dealings with historic sexual abuse complaints related to its former Christchurch boys' home, Marylands.

2004-0312 - The Press - Abuse complaints
A new Catholic Church office to oversee abuse complaints will be set up within the next few months. Catholic bishops and leaders of religious orders agreed last year that a body was needed to evaluate and supervise complaints procedures. Sexual-abuse complaints will still be dealt with by professional-standards committees in the country's six diocese and by those operated by religious orders

2004-0310 - Dominion Post - Catholics and the past
Letter to the Editor by Brian Harmer - Jim Scott (Letters, March 6) suggests that abuse within the Catholic Church should disbar it from speaking out on Treaty issues… The abusers referred to by Mr Scott do not characterise the whole church. Grave crimes such as these must of course be deplored, and the guilty brought to justice. That does not mean that the rest of the church, including its bishops, are absolved from their obligation to speak out against injustice

2004-0307 - Sunday Star Times - Mel's SM-BD porn
Letter to the Editor by Denis Hall - The more cynical among us, some Marist old boys, see a connection between all this and the huge problem of homosexual abuse, perpetrated by priests, now being exposed in the Catholic Church. I would characterise it as, dare I say it, "religious porn".

2004-0305 - Dominion Post - A dollar each way
Letter to the Editor by Murray Hunter - Twenty Catholic and Anglican bishops oppose Don Brash's views on the Treaty and race-based privileges. Yet Bishop Dunn, in refusing legal obligation by the Catholic Church for sex abuse by its priests, has said that "I cannot see that a later generation is in some way liable for the harm done by a deceased person".

2004-0228 - NZ Herald - Bishop disputes liability for sex abuse
by Eugene Bingham - The Catholic Bishop of Auckland told three brothers sexually abused by a priest that the church was not legally responsible for his actions. Bishop Patrick Dunn's comments have stunned the three men and surprised lawyers, who say the church is liable - regardless of whether it knew about the offending at the time. The three brothers, Mike, Gerry and Chris Ledingham, have reached a $150,000 settlement over abuse they suffered in an Auckland parish 40 years ago. But they remain horrified by the church's approach to handling sexual abuse complaints.

2004-0228 - Newstalk ZB - Bishop's comments defended
Auckland's Catholic Bishop has caused outrage with his comments about a sexual abuse case. Three brothers who were violated in an Auckland parish four decades ago have received a payout from the Catholic church. Bishop Patrick Dunn has told the brothers the church is not legally responsible for their compensation. The Catholic church is defending the comments.

2004-0227 - The Press - 'Abuse complaint met with severe thrashing'
by Jarrod Booker - A boy at a Christchurch St John of God school had to be dragged kicking and screaming back to school after holiday breaks, his mother told a court yesterday. The mother was giving evidence at a Christchurch District Court depositions hearing into charges against a former brother at the Marylands school. Bernard Kevin McGrath faces 33 charges of sexual offending against boys at the school and was yesterday committed for trial. He was released on bail to a pre- trial conference in the High Court in Christchurch in April.

2004-0227 - The Press - Boy had to be dragged back to school, court told
A boy at a Christchurch St John of God school had to be dragged kicking and screaming back to school after holiday breaks, his mother told a court yesterday. The mother was giving evidence at a Christchurch District Court depositions hearing into charges against a former brother at the Marylands school. Bernard Kevin McGrath faces 33 charges of sexual offending against boys at the school and was yesterday committed for trial.

2004-0226 - The Press - Paid-out ex-pupil denies sexual abuse
An Australian religious order paid a disabled former pupil tens of thousands of dollars compensation for alleged mistreatment at its Christchurch school in the 1970s. At a depositions hearing in the Christchurch District Court yesterday, the court was told the St John of God order had paid a former pupil who had not claimed sexual abuse. Bernard Kevin McGrath, 56, faces 33 charges of sexual offending against boys under 16, alleged to have taken place in the 1970s while he was a brother at the Marylands school in Christchurch

2004-0225 - The Press - Helpers saw no offending
Helpers at a Christchurch school where alleged sexual offending took place against pupils say they saw no evidence of misconduct. Dorothy O'Connor worked from 1971 to 1977 at the St John of God Marylands School during which Brother Bernard Kevin McGrath, 56, was alleged to have sexually abused 18 boys under the age of 16. O'Connor, who was giving evidence yesterday at a depositions hearing in the Christchurch District Court via a video link from Melbourne, said she would sometimes talk to the pupils at the school but got no indication of any sexual or physical abuse having taken place

2004-0225 - The Press - No sex offence evidence, say St John of God helpers
Helpers at a Christchurch school where alleged sexual offending took place against pupils say they saw no evidence of misconduct. Dorothy O'Connor worked from 1971 to 1977 at the St John of God Marylands School during which Brother Bernard Kevin McGrath, 56, was alleged to have sexually abused 18 boys under age 16.

2004-0223 - Newstalk ZB - More abuse cases come for
Number of people claiming sexual, phsyical or mental abuse in children's institutions has tripled in a month. The number of former children's institution inmates claiming they were sexually, physically and mentally abused has tripled in a little over a month. Sonja Cooper first raised the issue in public on behalf of around 40 people who claim they were abused in the 50s and 60s in state-owned children's homes

2004-0219 - Otago Daily Times - Former Campbell Park pupil dismissive of allegations
A growing number of former Campbell Park School pupils are coming forward with stories of the abuse they suffered there. Wellington lawyer Sonja Cooper yesterday said she had already heard from 10 or 11 men who had attended the Otekaieke school. When the abuse allegations first became public last month, she had spoken to five ex-pupils. As media coverage of trouble at the institution continued, more had contacted her.

2004-0219 - NZ Herald - Ex-pupils tell of abuses
A growing number of former Campbell Park School pupils are coming forward with stories of the abuse they suffered there. Wellington lawyer Sonja Cooper said she had already heard from 10 or 11 men who had attended the Otekaieke school.

2004-0218 - NZ Herald - Woman's case against Church heads to High C
The case of a Christchurch woman suing the Catholic Church over its handling of a complaint against a priest will go to the High Court next month. Bonnie Quilter, a Shirley invalid beneficiary, is seeking exemplary damages and an inquiry into the Church's abuse complaints procedures. She is one of four women who laid complaints of sexual misconduct against former Lyttelton priest Father Jim Consedine.

2004-0217 - The Press - Court date for abuse complaint against priest
The case of a Christchurch woman suing the Catholic Church over its handling of a complaint against a priest will go to the High Court next month. Bonnie Quilter, a Shirley invalid beneficiary, is seeking exemplary damages and an inquiry into the church's abuse complaints procedures.

2004-0217 - Otago Daily Times - Case against church next month
NZPA - The case of a Christchurch woman suing the Catholic Church over its handling of a complaint against a priest will go to the High Court next month. Bonnie Quilter, a Shirley invalid beneficiary, is seeking exemplary damages and an inquiry into the church's abuse complaints procedures. She is one of four women who laid complaints of sexual misconduct against former Lyttelton priest Fr Jim Consedine.

2004-0216 - The Press - Counselling
Letter to the Editor by Phillip Rex Robinson - David Dawe (February 3) asks when the cult of counselling began. During the 1980s ACC decided to pay lump sum compensation to people claiming sexual abuse. The Privacy Act means no rigorous proof or criminal prosecution is required, the psychoanalysis of a counsellor being deemed sufficient to establish entitlement. Like non-judgmental priests and doctors, counsellors must give a value-free service, so expecting counsellors to identify possible fraudsters is unrealistic. Not only is it against their own financial interests, but also their professional ethics.

2004-0213 - The Press - Sisters of Nazareth
Letter to the Editor by C J Popplewell - In reference to Yvonne Martin's article (December 24), as with Peter Leeming and M. Wagteveld, I too was appalled at this article, which was dramatic and unbalanced. As a former resident of seven years, I received or witnessed no such physical abuse from the Sisters of Nazareth. So, I decided to attend the mediation process to meet face to face with the complainants, but much to my frustration only one decided to front-up to the many people who had travelled from all parts of the country in support of the Sisters of Nazareth.

2004-0206 - The Press - Ex-St John of God man to face sex charge trial
A former St John of God brother has been committed to trial to face eight sex charges after a District Court depositions hearing yesterday. Justices of the Peace John O'Hara and Marie Fahey did not require the man, whose name is suppressed, to appear for a High Court pre-trial hearing on March 5. He was remanded on bail and allowed to travel back to his home in Queensland.

2004-0206 - Otago Daily Times - Former brother for trial on sex charges
A former St John of God brother has been committed for trial on eight sex abuse charges after a depositions hearing in the Christchurch District Court yesterday. Justices of the Peace John O'Hara and Marie Fahey said the man, whose name is suppressed, was not required to appear for a High Court pre-trial hearing on March 5. He was remanded on bail and allowed to travel back to his home in Queensland. He had returned voluntarily to New Zealand to face charges involving five former pupils at Marylands Special School in Halswell, Christchurch.

2004-0206 - NZ Herald - Former St John of God brother faces eight sex abuse charges
A former St John of God brother has been committed for trial on eight sex abuse charges. The man, whose name is suppressed, was remanded on bail and allowed to return to Queensland. A High Court trial date will be set for a March pre-trial hearing

2004-0205 - One News - Catholic brother to face trial
A former Catholic brother has been committed to stand trial for sexually abusing young boys. The 64-year-old man, who lives in Australia and whose name is suppressed, worked at a residential school in Christchurch run by the St John of God order between 1966 and 1974. He is accused of abusing five pupils, aged between eight and 15, during his time at the school for boys with learning difficulties.

2004-0205 - Dominion Post - Woodcock in court
Former Catholic priest Alan Woodcock made a brief appearance in Upper Hutt District Court yesterday facing charges relating to sexually abusing boys

2004-0129 - NZ Herald - Extradition hearing for churchmen on sex abuse charges set
NZPA - A hearing opposing the extradition of three Catholic clergymen to New Zealand to face child sex abuse charges will be heard in Sydney in May. A three-day hearing has been set down in Downing Centre Local Court, starting on May 10, the two brothers and a priest were told today. Magistrate Robert Abood continued their bail until then. The men - aged 82, 68 and 56 - are members of the St John of God order. New Zealand police have filed 37 sexual abuse charges against them

2004-0126 - Dominion Post - 90 claimants now signed up over abuse
by Fran Tyler - The number of people who have signed up to a combined lawsuit over alleged abuse in state-run children's homes has risen to about 90. Recent publicity about the case in The Dominion Post resulted in about 45 more people coming forward claiming they too suffered sexual, physical or emotional abuse while in the homes in the 1950s, 60s and 70s. The claims had come from all over New Zealand, lawyer Sonja Cooper said. She described some of the stories as "horrific".

2004-0122 - Stuff - Accused priest gravely ill, says lawyer
NZPA - One of the Catholic clergymen facing child sex abuse charges in New Zealand was gravely ill with cancer, his lawyer told a Sydney court yesterday. Three members of the St John of God order are opposing an extradition bid by New Zealand authorities which would have them facing 37 charges in Christchurch relating to allegations of sexual assault.

2004-0121 - Wairarapa Times Age - Former govt home residents say they were locked in attic
Past residents of the former government-run Fareham House in the Wairarapa town of Featherston say they were locked in an attic for weeks on end or forced to clean a hall floor with a toothbrush. Fareham House last week joined other former Department of Social Welfare homes around New Zealand in facing allegations of abuse from the 1960s and 1970s. About 60 people are suing the Government over their treatment. They are mostly former inmates of Epuni Boys Home in Lower Hutt, Hokio Beach Training Centre near Levin, Campbell Park School in Otekaike, North Otago, Miramar Girls Receiving Home in Wellington, Kohitere Boys Training Centre in Levin as well as Fareham, during the 1960s and 1970s.

2004-0121 - One News - Catholic brothers in Sydney court
A 56-year-old Catholic priest facing child sex charges laid in New Zealand was terminally ill, and two co-accused Brothers were very ill, a Sydney court has been told. St John of God priest Raymond Garchow and Brothers William Lebler, 82, and Rodger Maloney, 68, are facing a total of 61 sexual assault charges against their former students, dating back almost 50 years.

2004-0121 - NZ Herald - Extradited sex-charge priest granted bail
NZPA - A former Wellington Catholic priest extradited from Britain on child-sex charges was released on bail when he appeared in the Upper Hutt District Court yesterday. Alan Woodcock faces 34 charges involving 11 boys dating back more than 20 years

2004-0121 - Dominion Post - Ex-priest bailed on child sex charges
NZPA - A former Catholic priest extradited from Britain on child sex charges has been bailed in Upper Hutt District Court. Alan Woodcock, formerly of Upper Hutt, faces 34 charges, involving 11 boys, dating back more than 20 years.

2004-0120 - NZ Herald - Extradited former priest remanded on bail      New June 7 2004
A former Wellington Catholic priest extradited from Britain over child-sex charges was remanded on bail when he appeared in Upper Hutt District Court this morning. Alan Woodcock, formerly of Upper Hutt, lived in England from the late 1980s but a High Court decision issued from London in November ruled he must return to New Zealand to face trial on charges involving 12 boys dating back more than 20 years

2004-0120 - Newstalk ZB - Extradited former priest in court     New June 7 2004
A court appearance today for a former priest facing sexual assault charges. Alan Woodcock was extradited from England and arrived in New Zealand over the weekend. He is charged with indecently assaulting 12 teenage boys between 1982 and 1985 while he was teaching at schools in Upper Hutt and Palmerston North.

2004-0120 - Newstalk ZB - Bail granted for former priest     New June 7 2004
Bail has been granted to a former priest accused of sexually assaulting young boys. Alan John Woodcock is facing more than 30 charges, for allegedly indecently assaulting 12 teenage boys while he was teaching at schools in Upper Hutt and Palmerston North between 1982 and 1985

2004-0119 - Dominion Post - Extradited priest back in NZ
by Kim Ruscoe - The former Wellington Catholic priest extradited from England to face child-sex assault charges is back in New Zealand. Alan Woodcock is being held in the Upper Hutt police cells till his court appearance tomorrow. Woodcock has lived in England since the late 1980s.

2004-0117 - One News - Woodcock back to face charges
A former Catholic priest has arrived back in New Zealand to face child sex charges. Alan Woodcock, who has been extradited from Britain, flew back under police guard. The 54-year-old is charged with 34 counts of sexually abusing children while he was a teacher in Silverstream, Upper Hutt and Palmerston North in the 1980s.

2004-0117 - Otago Daily Times - A 'culture of abuse'
Ms Cooper hoped to lodge legal proceedings in one of the Campbell Park cases in the near future. The other was progressing more slowly because of the frailty of the victim, she said. Bruce Willis, who was a Campbell Park head teacher in the 1970s, said he was not surprised to hear of the allegations as institutions sometimes attracted a "certain type" of person. "But, overall, Campbell Park did a pretty good job …. as it provided boys with security and work skills."

2004-0116 - Otago Daily Times - Plan to sue over abuse of children
NZPA - Almost 50 former inmates of children's institutions plan to sue the Government over accusations of abuse and claims of a cover-up. The group of about 45 were mostly inmates during the 1960s and 1970s of Campbell Park School, in Otekaike, North Otago; Epuni Boys Home, Lower Hutt; Hokio Beach Training Centre, near Levin; Miramar Girls Receiving Home, Wellington; Fareham House girls' home, Wairarapa; and Kohitere Boys Training Centre, Levin. Spearheaded by Wellington lawyers Sonja Cooper and Carla Leader, the combined legal action claims the treatment of the children robbed them of their education and forced many of them into a pattern of crime, violence, drug and alcohol abuse, unemployment and failed relationships.

2004-0116 - Newstalk ZB - Abuse allegations in Govt institutions
45 former children's institute residents claim they suffered mental, physical and sexual abuse while in Government's care. The Government could have to pay out for alleged abuse in girls' and boys' homes around the Wellington region in the 1960s and '70s. Forty-five former children's institute residents are putting a case together which include claims of mental, physical and sexual abuse, mostly at six centres. Lawyer Sonja Cooper says some of the victims' accounts are harrowing and as she interviews more of them, it is becoming clear what went on in the institutions.

2004-0116 - Dominion Post - Woodcock to return
A former Wellington Catholic priest being extradited from Britain to face child sex-assault charges is expected back in New Zealand shortly. Alan Woodcock, formerly of Upper Hutt….

2004-0116 - Dominion Post - Violent upbringings away from home
By Fran Tyler - A group of about 45 men who say they suffered abuse in boys' homes are planning legal action against the Crown. Fran Tyler spoke to some of them about their experiences.

2004-0116 - Dominion Post - Difficult kids were helped, says ex-head
by Fran Tyler - Thousands of New Zealand children have passed through welfare homes, developed to provide a nurturing environment and education for troubled children. The social worker manual of the 1960s describes one home as: "to provide for the social re-education of delinquent boys from about 14 to 17 years, who are unsuitable for foster home placement". But over the years various reports, and a number of people sent to homes, have highlighted abuse. A Human Rights Commission inquiry into the treatment of children in social welfare homes was held in 1980. The commission's report, published in 1982, outlined brutal punishment of welfare home children. The commission made a series of recommendations.

2004-0115 - The Press - Catholic brothers to oppose extradition
by Yvonne Martin - Three Catholic brothers have indicated they will oppose extradition from Australia to face sex abuse charges in New Zealand. The St John of God brothers, aged 56, 67 and 81, have been arrested by federal police in Sydney after the Christchurch District Court issued warrants to arrest in November. Christchurch police have laid a total of 47 charges against the trio, after complaints from former pupils dating back almost 50 years. The claims of abuse relate to when the brothers taught at Marylands,

2004-0115 - One News - Accused likely to fight extradition
Police in Christchurch say three brothers from the Catholic order, St John of God, who are accused of sex abuse have indicated they will oppose extradition from Australia to face the charges. Police have laid 47 charges against the men, aged 56, 67 and 81, following investigations over complaints by former pupils at the order's Marylands Residential School in Christchurch

2004-0115 - Otago Daily Times - Abuse at Sedgley spanned 40 years
NZPA - New information has shown sexual offending at the former Sedgley Boys Home in Masterton spanned four decades, more than two perpetrators and multiple victims, the inquiry set up to investigate the offending has discovered. Previously, the sexual offending was thought to be confined to one period and one offender in the 1960s. Now, Sedgley inquiry spokeswoman Lisa Rossiter has said the offending was not isolated and happened at times between the 1940s and 1970s. "Unfortunately, there is more than one victim and more than one perpetrator.

2004-0115 - NZ Herald - Former priest expected back in next few days to face charges
NZPA - A former Wellington Catholic priest being extradited from Britain to face child sex-assault charges is expected to be back in New Zealand in the next few days. Alan Woodcock, formerly of Upper Hutt…..

2004-0113 - The Press - Man guilty of false claim against priests
by John Henzell - A Christchurch man who lied about being repeatedly molested by paedophile priests at a St John of God school has been told he had made life even more difficult for genuine victims. John Kevin Fenn, 39, a sickness beneficiary with intellectual disabilities, claimed that he had been repeatedly molested during eight years at the Halswell school in the 1970s. But when detectives uncovered inconsistencies in his story, Fenn admitted he had not been molested and had made up the abuse claim in a bid to get compensation from the order. Fenn pleaded guilty in the Christchurch District Court to a charge of making a false statement to police