Last updated March 19 2005
2001-1231 - Usenet - New Zealand Honours Awarded
Humour …lighthearted …but with a serious
message News of the day: Lynley
Dodd (author of Hairy McClary series
of children’s books) is given New Zealand’s highest honour ……Steve Bell
writes - For one joyful but incredulous moment, I thought the award of
Distinguished Companion of the NZ Order of Merit had been given to Lynley
Hood. (Ms Dodd deserved it too, of
course.)
2001-1231 - Hamilton City Libraries - Top Ten List
A City Possessed is an
unusual book in the miscarriage of justice literature and the Peter Ellis
case is an unusual case
2001-1230 - Investigate Jan 2002 - A City Possessed
January 2002, Page 80,
Review by Michael Morrissey - Lynley Hood, an accomplished biographer, has
focused her considerable talents on the highly controversial Peter Ellis
case……
2001-1230 - Woman Today - A City Possessed
Summer 2001/2002 Issue 008,
page 5 - Feature, A City Possessed,
Review by Lucy di Maggio - Whenever a high-profile criminal case comes to
court, we wonder: Is the person charged guilty or innocent? Will all the
facts come to light? Just what is the truth anyway?
2001-1229 - The Press - Six Of The Best
Six of the Best – Who made a
difference in 2001? - Includes Lynley Hood), by Geoff Collett In November, 10 years to the month since
the Christchurch Civic Creche case was launched onto its infamous course,
Lynley Hood delivered what to many minds is the most compelling evidence yet
that the case has been a travesty
2001-1228 - Otago Daily Times - Guilty until proven
innocent
by Dave Witherow – I have
just finished reading a new book by Mike Kalaugher ......This has become a worry.
Coming hard on the heels of Lynley Hood's monumental work on the Peter Ellis
fiasco, it further erodes what minimal credibility still adheres to the
police, the courts and the judiciary
2001-1224 - Listener - Letter by Lynley Hood
Letter, Page 8, by Lynley
Hood : “Ten reasons why state broadcasting should interview me about A City
Possessed”
2001-1224 - Listener - Letter Doubt expressed
Letter, Page 8, by Chris
Wheatley - Like many others, I wonder whether Peter Ellis should have been
convicted, for all the good reasons in all the objections subsequently
raised…..
2001-1224 - Listener - Letter Unbelievable does not
equate to innocence
Letter, Page 8, by C King -
2001-1220 - Otago Daily Times - Letter to the Editor
by Richard Smith - the Peter
Ellis case represents one of the most disgraceful episodes in our history
2001-1219 - Otago Daily Times - Letter to the Editor
by AJ Lemm - I challenge Mr
Goff to consider the findings in Lynley Hood's book, A City Possessed , and
have the integrity to implement a commission of inquiry or pardon Peter
Ellis. The truth will ultimately surface
2001-1216 - Sunday Star Times - Goff needs moral
courage
Page A6, by Lynley Hood -
Justice Minister Phil Goff (December 9) has misrepresented my position. I am not an advocate for anyone involved in
the Christchurch Civic Creche case…..If the royal pardon is to serve it’s
proper function as a constitutional safeguard against judicial mistakes, the
minister must find the moral courage and political will to act when it is
obvious that the judiciary has made a serious mistake
2001-1216 - Sunday Star Times - Back To Goff
Page A6, by Lesley Ellis -
The appeal court judges, far from concurring on the verdict, suggested the
case would be better dealt with by a commission of inquiry. The urge for that comes not only from
Lynley Hood, but from academics, coalface QCs, lawyers, journalists and the
public in general. The ball is in your
court, Mr Goff
2001-1216 - Sunday Star Times - Frank Haden Column
Page C6, by Frank Haden;
including a poem by David Hood - Once I admired Phil Goff. A most pleasant
fellow to meet, …. Now he’s ruined everything with his blinkered refusal to
read Lynley Hood’s book proving the unsustainability of Peter Ellis’s
conviction.
2001-1215
- Daily News - Justice hard to find in a city possessed
review by Jim Tucker; “Hood proves
there is reasonable doubt that Ellis was guilty beyond reasonable doubt”....
It takes great courage to step outside mainstream thought and suggest it is
not OK to distort the law, condone over-zealous counselling and police-work,
and cause collateral damage in a quest to rid the country of child molesters.
This is what Hood, a 58-year-old Dunedin scientist, writer and grandmother,
has done in this book. It cost her dearly, by all accounts
2001-1212 - Otago Daily Times - Courage needed to
address Ellis issues
page 12, Lynley Hood responds to Minister of
Justice, Phil Goff - ”Justice Minister Phil Goff has misrepresented my
position. I am not an advocate for anyone involved in the Christchurch Civic
Creche case. Mr Goff is being poorly advised”
2001-1212 - Otago Daily Times - Ellis case remains
enigma of criminal justice system
page 13 Judith Ablett Kerr responds to Minister of
Justice, Phil Goff - The Peter Ellis case has never been
"fully" considered by any of the tribunals relied on by the
Minister of Justice, Phil Goff, in denying further consideration of the
Christchurch Civic Creche case
I found it highly unusual for a minister to personally respond to such an editorial,
and can only assume that the contents of it had made sufficient impact to
engender a reply. I would not normally choose to use Letters to the Editor as
a vehicle to debate any case of mine, but I feel that I cannot allow the
minister's letter to go without response. Your readers are entitled to know
that the Peter Ellis case has never been "fully" considered by any
of the tribunals mentioned in the minister's letter
2001-1212 - Otago Daily Times - Letter to the Editor
by E.A. McRae – The wilfully
blinkered attitude of Minister of Justice Phil Goff is well illustrated by
his letter (8.12.01). The arguments with which he attempts to dismiss Lynley
Hood's dispassionate examination of the facts surrounding Peter Ellis' case
would immediately be dealt with by reading the book; but even in the face of
considered opinions from many stalwarts of the legal community, he refused to
bother
2001-1212 - Otago Daily Times - Peter Ellis - the
system guilty?
Page 12, Letter to the
Editor by R.E. Mawson - ”To pardon Mr Ellis now is to find the system guilty,
and I suspect that this is the reason for Justice Minister Phil Goff's
reluctance to read Lynley Hood's book, A City Possessed”
2001-1211 - Otago Daily Times - Independent tribunal
urged
The
Justice Minister Phil Goff should establish an independent body to consider
claims of wrongful conviction from convicted offenders such as Peter Ellis,
David Bain and Rex Haig, a leading lawyer said yesterday. The call came from
Nigel Hampton QC, who lodged his second bid for a pardon for Haig with the
Governor-General
2001-1210 - If Dr Seuss were Minister of Justice
A must read!!!
by David
Hood - I will not read that book by
Hood, I will not, will not, say it’s
good ….
2001-1210 - North and South - Update 2001 : November
Under the Hood
Article, page 45, Summary of
articles. 2001 : Hood’s Book
A City Possessed – Lynley hood’s epic tome investigating the Christchurch
Civic Creche child abuse case – shot straight into the top 10 New Zealand
books on the Booksellers’ best-seller list on release in October
2001-1210 - North and South - Slow Readers?
Letter, page 15, by Robert
Hayward - the Civic Creche case has been put into the context of the criminal
justice system, police investigation and child interview techniques and the
history of public hysteria, I fear the problem has become too big to deal
with. A fear that a thorough official examination of the case would open up a
can of worms so huge that it could not be contained by anything - including
the government
2001-1210 - North and South - At Last! Praise for
Hood's book
Letters, page 12, by Peter
du Chateau - Thank you for November’s article by Lauren Quaintance on the
Peter Ellis sex abuse investigation at the Christchurch Civic Creche. I am a
retired educational psychologist with an increasing sense of concern and
dismay at the outcomes so far and am pleased to see the justified publicity
given to Lynley Hood’s new book A City Possessed
2001-1210 - North and South - Just doing her job
letter, page 12, by Ros
Henry - Your article on Lynley Hood’s book made interesting reading. The
first part, an analysis of the work of an investigative journalist and the
moral and legal issues she tangled with along the way, was absorbing. I’m
afraid, however, I lost sympathy completely with the second part of the
feature, which deals with a world with which I’m very familiar. I take
extreme issue with your writer’s description of the role Anna Rogers played
2001-1210 - North and South - Unwarranted and
ill-informed
Letter, page 12, by Juliet
Rogers - The unwarranted and ill-informed attack on my sister, in Lauren
Quaintance’s November article on Lynley Hood’s book has, however, led me to
change my position
2001-1209 - Sunday Star Times - Criminal Sacrifice
Letter to Editor by Nancy
Trevathan - No children or anyone else in this country should be able to be
sacrificed to protect any system, let alone the criminal justice system
2001-1209 - Sunday Star Times - Ellis Trials - by
Goff
Letter to Editor by Minister
of Justice Phil Goff
”Against Lynley Hood's view that Peter Ellis is innocent are the combined and
unanimous views of the judge and jury who found him guilty; the views of
seven Appeal Court judges who in two separate appeals upheld the conviction;
and the views of a Ministerial Inquiry who found that Ellis' arguments failed
"by a distinct margin" to satisfy him that the convictions were
unsafe”.
2001-1208 - Christchurch Star - Commission Of
Inquiry Proposed
Page A6, by Guy Grant, “Commission of Inquiry proposed for Ellis
Case”
”A commission of inquiry along the lines of South Africa's truth and
reconciliation commission may be one way of dealing with the ongoing debate
over the Christchurch Civic Creche case, says author Lynley Hood”.
2001-1208 - Otago Daily Times - Minister Justice
writes about Peter Ellis
Page A22, Letters to the Editor,
by Minister of Justice, Phil Goff
2001-1208 - The Listener - Editorial : Whiffs Of
Injustice
Editorial by Bruce
Ansley; “injustice is corrosive.
It lingers. Only a public inquiry can resolve it now”.
2001-1208
- Hawkes Bay Today - Modern day witch hunt uncovered
review by Peter de Graaf; “Whatever you
make of Hood's conclusion, A City Possessed can only cast more doubt
on Ellis' convictions and on our legal processes. But more chilling still is
the thought of how little has changed from 17th century Salem to 20th century
Christchurch”.
2001-1206 - Ind Newspapers - Methodology similar to
that used against Ellis
Feedback by Kathleen Murdoch
2001-1206 - Ind Newspapers - Techniques same as at Creche
Feedback by Carolyn Lewis
2001-1205 - Otago Daily Times - Justice Possessed
Opinion, Editorial, Goff
should read Lynley Hoods Book
2001-1204 - The Press - A City Possessed
Letter to Editor by Mary
Baker
2001-1202 - Sunday Star Times - Get Ellis Case Right
Page A10, Letter to Editor
by Rob Mawson
2001-1202 - Sunday Star Times - Inquiry
Page A10, Letter to Editor
by Gordon Waugh - A royal commission
should review the entire spectrum of the sex abuse industry, the Evidence
Act, the nonsense of allowing “expert” witnesses and the assault on common
sense of not requiring corroboration
2001-1202 - Sunday Star Times - Stubborn Goff
Page A10, Letter to Editor
by E.N.Williams – I am disappointed Phil Goff has chosen to ignore
the research and common sense in Lynley Hood’s book
2001-1200 - Ministry Justice - Process for Royal
prerogative to be reviewed
The process for dealing with applications for the Royal prerogative of mercy,
a safeguard of New Zealand's criminal justice system, is to be reviewed.
2001-1129 - Independent Newspapers - Ellis Must Be
Pardoned
Feedback by Kath O’Sullivan
- After reading the alleged remark of Mr Goff, re the Peter Ellis debacle, I
am beginning to wonder if he has turned into an ostrich.
2001-1126 The Press
Front Page by Martin Van
Beynen “Goff Should Read Book on Creche Case”
A recently published and acclaimed book about the Christchurch creche case
should be on Justice Minister Phil Goff's required holiday reading list,
Peter Ellis says
2001-1125 - Sunday Star Times - Legal Calls Grow
Page A2 by Donna Chisholm
”Legal muscle is gathering behind author Lynley Hood's bid to put the Peter
Ellis case back on the political agenda.
Hood’s A City Possessed on the Christchurch Civic Creche investigation
provides a compelling case for Ellis' innocence of the child sexual abuse
charges for which he spent seven years in
2001-1121 - The Press - A City Possessed
Page 10, Letter to the
Editor by Mollie and Gordon Seatter
”Congratulations to Cynthia Hawes on her closely studied and extremely fair
review of Lynley Hood’s book, A City Possessed (November 3)”.
2001-1112 - North and South - They got it wrong
by Gordon Waugh - Your
article on Lynley Hood and her new book "A City Possessed"
(November) was excellent..... "A City Possessed" provides adequate
reason to exonerate Ellis and return common sense to a justice system misled
by self-appointed experts. Ms Hood is correct. They got it wrong. Again
2001-1112 - North and South - Review of A City
Possessed
page 116, review of A City
Possessed by Chris Bourke - ”The case is tragic because, apart from Ellis,
hundreds of lives were damaged, families broken up, careers ruined. Yet still
there’s a nagging doubt that the accusations were fantasy, a product of
fevered imaginations fed by prejudice and zealotry”.
2001-1111 - Sunday Star Times - Abuse Doubts
Page A8, Letter to the
Editor by Joyce Gibson
2001-1109 - Evening Post - New Zealands J'Accuse
Elric Hooper compares case
with French Dreyfus treason case
2001-1107 - Christchurch Star - Book Packed With
Fact
Page B3, Letter to the
Editor by N Sutherland
2001-1104 - Sunday Star Times - Creche Silence
Page A10, Letter to the
Editor by Robert G Hayward -
2001-1103 - The Press - Exposing The Flaws
Page 20, Book Review by
Cynthia Hawes “A City Possessed, Exposing the Flaws”
”Lynley Hood's entry into the fray with her well written and closely
researched book is a brave stand for the application of objectivity and
rationality, qualities which she considers to have been seriously lacking
during the investigation and trial of Peter Ellis”
2001-11 - NZ Early Childhood Symposium - Dec 2001
Notice of Lynley Hood being
keynote speaker at forthcoming conference
2001-1031 - NZ G P - Modern Day Witch Hunters
Book Review by Dr Jim
Hefford “Modern-Day Witch-hunters, A City Possessed”
2001-1030 - Marlborough Express - A City Possessed
Book Review by Sandra Carson
”This book is essentially about the Peter Ellis case, but even if you don't
care one way or the other about that, the book should still be read for its
fascinating insight into our legal system, laws and bureaucracies”
2001-1029 - Evening Post - A City Possessed
Book Review by Bernard
Robertson
”The case is unusual because most miscarriage of justice cases are about
whether the accused committed the offences, or someone else. In this case the
question is whether the offences took place at all. The book is unusual
because it takes in far more than just the story of the case. In particular
Lynley Hood gives us an intelligent and astute criticism of changes made in
1989 to the rules of evidence for child sexual abuse cases and also of the
limits, imposed by Parliament or by the court itself, to the Court of
Appeal's powers to review cases properly on appeal
2001-1029 - Evening Post - Fresh Charge Unlikely
Page 2
2001-1027 - Conference Paper - The day I almost went
to Jail
Australian Centre for Independent
Journalism, 26-28 October 2001
By Lynley Hood, “The day I almost went
to jail and other stories”
2001-1027 - Dominion - A Man Wronged
Book Review by Dave Smith “A
Man Wronged? : A City Possessed”
”with searing passion she has authored a cogent overview of what posterity
might view as New Zealand's equivalent of the Salem witch trials……”
2001-1024 - Christchurch Star - Representativeness
Letter to the Editor by E
Watson
2001-1023 - The Capital Letter
by Penny Pepperell: “The
Christchurch Civic Creche Case”
”the book challenges the reader to examine how their opinion of this case
(and everyone it seems has one) may have been moulded by the social belief
structures of the day rather than the facts”
2001-1020 - Otago Daily Times - Ellis case book
races to top spot on sales list
by
Marjorie Cook - Lynley Hood's controversial book, A City Possessed - The
Christchurch Creche Case, has rocketed to No 1 on the best-seller list, two
weeks after its release.
2001-1020 - Otago Daily Times - Disturbing insights
in creche case
by
Gavin McLean - This is an important, engrossing and, as I said at the start,
a highly disturbing book. Whether you believe Peter Ellis's innocence or not
- and I am inclined to - it is worth reading and discussing for the wider
issues that emerge. At a time when educators and parents are lamenting the
poor performance of boys in schools, any ideological and legal barriers to
males entering the caring and teaching professions should be examined closely
2001-1020 - NZ Herald - Lynley Hood A City Possessed
by Sarah Farquhar - No other
case of child abuse in New Zealand's history has held public attention so strongly
and for so long as the Christchurch Civic Creche case
2001-1019 - Manawatu Evening Standard
Page 14, Book Review by Mike
Behrens - This book devastated me and certainly laid waste law makers, sexual
abuse professionals, child protection workers, policemen, lawyers, judges,
parents and any image we might have of ourselves as a thinking, caring
culture immune from nonsense
2001-1018 - Manawatu Evening
Standard
Front Page by Dave Mahoney : “Ellis should receive pardon: Behrens”
2001-1015 - North and South November
Issue
by Lauren Quaintance - It’s over eight years since Dunedin writer Lynley hood began a book
on the Christchurch Civic Creche sexual abuse case. During that time she’s
been accused of keeping an innocent man in prison for personal gain,
threatened with jail by the Court of Appeal and fallen out with her original
publishers. Meanwhile, doubters said her 230,000-word magnum opus – published
this month by plucky Longacre Press – would never make it to bookshop
shelves. Lauren Quaintance reports on The
Lonely Journey Of Lynley Hood - 0n the first page of A City Possessed Lynley Hood says writing the book "often
felt like the literary equivalent of a solo crossing of Antarctica".
"There were points," Hood told North & South, "where I
thought 'this is too hard' but there were never points where I felt like
stopping or that I had to give up or I couldn't move. At times I felt like
I'd fallen down a crevasse and the only thing to do was to get out my ice-axe
and ropes and drag myself up and trudge on or die in the attempt."
2001-1012
- National Business Review - VUW-Creche Book Controversy
Page 2 by Nick Smith
2001-10 - New Zealand Law Journal
Cover Story; Book Review by Ian Freckelton
2001-1009 - The Press - A
City Possessed
Letter to Editor by John Blumsky
2001-1008 - Otago Daily Times - 'Ellis case similar
to US trial'
NZPA - A woman, who headed legal teams that
successfully appealed against convictions in a US child sex abuse case, says
it seems to have striking similarities with the Christchurch Civic Creche
case. University of Washington criminal law clinic director Jackie McMurtrie
said repetitive interviewing of children, interviewers predisposed to finding
abuse, and allegations "growing from something relatively minor"
were among the similarities. The US case, in Wenatchee, Washington, led to
more than 60 adults being arrested on 29,726 charges of sex abuse involving
43 children
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Ellis and an abuse
of justice
by
Peter Parkinson - A City Possessed should be compulsory reading for all the
judiciary, counsellors, psychologists and everyone else riding the gravy
train of the abuse industry. That we have got it so wrong for so long is
beyond belief. Maybe now we can count the cost, take stock and try to get it
right.
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Ellis Innocent
by
Alex Love - Thank-you Lynley Hood
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Justice Denied
by
Gordon Waugh - Lynley Hood's new book on the Peter Ellis case crystallises
the problems underlying the sex abuse industry. Ellis and his co-workers were
denied justice to save the reputations of people predisposed to believe
sexual abuse fantasies and conspiracies
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Old Coals
by
Brian Hartley - …..one has to wonder if revisiting the past in this instance
may be decidedly more harmful than helpful given the controversy and
highly-charged emotion…..
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Hoodwinked?
by
M Hallam - Lynley Hood invokes "and of course no inmate laid a finger on
him in prison" as a "pointer to Ellis' innocence". …….I've
heard of jumping to conclusions, but Hood's logical leaps are in the realm of
extreme sport.
2001-1007 - Sunday Star Times - Abuse Epidemic
by
Ken Clearwater - ….. It is known that one in four girls will be sexually
abused in this country before their 16th birthday. There are now figures
coming through that the number of boys is the same as girls. …….It is also
important that people realise there are cases of ritual abuse in this
country. There should be an immediate inquiry into the sexual abuse of
children in New Zealand.
2001-1005
- Otago Daily Times - Ellis Claims Not Moving Officials
Page 3 by Joanna Norris
2001-1004 - New
Zealand Lawyer - A City Possessed
Page 21 Book Review by Ian Freckelton
2001-1003 - The Press - A date in court
The
following is a second extract from Lynley Hood's book, A City Possessed: The
Christchurch Civic Creche Case. Complainant families, and creche workers who
were not arrested, had their identities suppressed by court order. They
appear in the book under pseudonyms.
2001-1003 -
Christchurch Star - Book Like A Royal Commission
Page A3 by Donna Birkett - Former Christchurch Civic [Childcare Centre]
worker Peter Ellis ... is finding the new book about his case to be like a
royal commission of inquiry in itself.
2001-1003 - Christchurch
Star - Concern For Families
Fron Page by Amanda Breukelaar
2001-1003 -
Christchurch Star - Outsider Needs To Review
Front Page by Stacey Doornenbal
2001-1002 - Otago Daily Times - Positive reaction to
book
by
Craig Page - Dunedin author Lynley
Hood has had nothing but support following yesterday's release of her
controversial book about convicted child abuser Peter Ellis. "Everybody
has been extremely positive. People are saying good on you. It's about time
the truth came out," Ms Hood said last night at the book's launch in
Dunedin.
2001-1002 - The Press -
City Possessed Again
Page 5 by Rachel Walsh
2001-1002 -
Otago Daily Times - Author Pleased
“Author Pleased with Support for Book”
2001-1001 - Otago Daily Times - Shortage of evidence
of Ellis' guilt, author says
by
Kay Sinclair - Dunedin author Lynley Hood believes there is evidence pointing
to the innocence of Peter Ellis, quite apart from the lack of evidence of his
guilt. She did not start investigating the Christchurch Civic Creche case to
prove Ellis was innocent but rather to find out what did or did not happen,
Ms Hood told the Otago Daily Times . However, by the end of seven years of
research and writing, what she found convinced her the whole case had been
"constructed out of thin air".
2001-1001 - Otago Daily Times - 'No evidence' of
illegality at creche
by
Kay Sinclair - Child abuse is a major folk tale theme. In countless
spine-chilling stories, children are eaten by animals, murdered by
stepmothers, cooked by witches and abandoned by uncaring parents. Dunedin
author Lynley Hood spent more than seven years researching the Christchurch
Civic Child Care Centre case. Her conclusions on why Peter Ellis and four
female colleagues were charged with sexually abusing children at the creche
are the subject of a controversial new work, A City Possessed.
2001-1001 - Otago Daily Times - Hopes of new
material in book on Ellis
by
Joanna Norris - Convicted child-abuser Peter Ellis had been cautiously
looking forward to the release today of a book investigating his case and was
hopeful his name could be cleared, his lawyer said last night. The debate on
the conviction of Ellis for sexually abusing seven children is expected to
once again gain momentum today, when the book on his case by Dunedin author
Lynley Hood hits booksellers' shelves
2001-1001 -
Southland Times - Hoods painful quest for truth
by Rosemarie Smith - ”The book will undoubtedly cause pain to many of
those at the centre of the case but it is vital that the issues are
understood and seriously debated. If
nothing else, Hood seems to have given us all access to a body of evidence to
conduct an informed debate. For if Peter Ellis was wrongly convicted, and the
system cannot self- correct, none of us is safe before the law”
2001-1001 - Otago
Daily Times - Book may change way....
by Kay Sinclair “Book may change way
child abuse cases are dealt with. Dunedin law professor Mark Henaghan
believes Lynley Hood's study of the Christchurch Civic Creche case could lead
to some reassessing of decision-making processes relating to child sexual
abuse cases.One of the most important things A City Possessed did was question
the processes relating to expert evidence on whether children's behaviours
were consistent with sexual abuse, Prof Henaghan told the Otago Daily Times
last week
2001-1001 -
Dominion - Christchurch ripe for more abuse cases
Page 2 by Alan Samson – The "snobbery" of Christchurch and the
messianic zeal of some of its citizens were an almost inevitable spawning
ground for false charges against Peter Ellis, the author of the first book on
the 1993 child abuse case says. Speaking before publication of A City
Possessed, Lynley Hood said Christchurch in particular was ripe for another
creche case. It was "no surprise" "bizarre" claims
against Ellis arose in Christchurch.
2001-1001 - The Press
- Writer Ready for Backlash
Front Page by Jarrod Booker - Lynley Hood is bracing herself for an angry
backlash as her controversial book on the Christchurch civic creche sex abuse
case hits the shelves today. The Dunedin author said that her findings,
documented in A City Possessed, would raise serious doubt over the abuse
convictions of creche worker Peter Ellis and the workings of the justice
system as a whole.
2001-0930
- Sunday Star Times - Book Sparks Call
Front Page by Donna Chisholm : Book Sparks Call to Pardon Ellis – An author who
has spent seven years researching the Peter Ellis case has called for the
government to pardon Ellis and set up a commission of inquiry into the
criminal justice system. Lynley Hood's book A City Possessed, on the Christchurch Civic Creche case which saw
Ellis sentenced to 10 years' jail in 1993 for sexually abusing seven children
concludes he was the victim of a city's moral panic.
2001-0930 - Sunday
Star Times - Ellis In Blunderland
Page
C5-6 by Donna Chisholm - A new book on the Peter Ellis case concludes he was
the innocent victim of a city in the grip of mass hysteria. Open Lynley
Hood's latest book like an onion and peel back layer after layer of
injustice. Read it and weep. Put the cops in the Peter Ellis case on trial,
along with the sex abuse industry, social welfare, and the judiciary and
return the verdicts. Guilty, guilty, guilty.
And Ellis? Convict him of having a big mouth and long fingernails. But
sexually abusing kids? No way.
2001-0929 - The Press - Creche
view 10 years on
by
Martin Van Beynen - A new book on the Christchurch Civic Creche case has
taken seven years of research by an award- winning author. Will it do
anything to dispel the murky shadow of doubt that still lingers over events
at the childcare centre? Nearly 10 years after the allegation that set in
train the Christchurch Civic Creche case, Peter Ellis will be queuing up with
everybody else to buy A City Possessed. The book, released for sale next
week, will cover the case's tortured and tortuous developments over a decade
in author Lynley Hood's trademark meticulously detailed and analytical style.
Seven years in the research and writing, the book has come too late to
influence the main official decisions about the case but, depending on its
contents, there are hopes in some quarters that it might still clear Ellis's
name.
2001-0929 - The Press - Old
Scars
by Staff Reporters - Police are refusing to be drawn on the status of
their investigations into a new complaint laid against Peter Ellis. A
20-year-old Christchurch man has approached the police with allegations that
he was sexually abused by Ellis when he was a young boy at the Christchurch
Civic Childcare Centre.
2001-0929 - The Press -
Unlikely to Disappoint
Feature article by Martin Van Beynen - After seven years of
waiting for Lynley Hood's A City Possessed, writes Martin van Beynen, many
will be expecting a monumental book. Given her previous books, Hood – a
reserved woman with a formidable intellect and indefatigible capacity for
work – is unlikely to disappoint.
2001-0929 - The Press - Last Word
by Martin Van Beynen - A new book on the Christchurch Civic Creche case
has taken seven years of research by an award-winning author. Will it do
anything to dispel the murky shadow of doubt that still lingers over events
at the childcare centre?
2001-0928 - TV
One News - Creche case back in Public Arena
The
Christchurch Civic Creche case is about to come under new scrutiny in a book
being launched on Monday. And people who have read the proof of the book say
it is set to reopen old wounds. The launch comes at a time when police are
close to deciding whether to proceed with a new charge against convicted
paedophile Peter Ellis
2001-0921 - Otago Daily Times - Third World justice
in New Zealand
by
Dave Witherow - The Peter Ellis saga was another demented demonstration of
comprehensive legal dysfunction. Its demonisation of Ellis, through a welter
of conflicting "evidence", should persuade all sensible people to
avoid like the plague anyone in the least associated with the psychiatric
professions.
A true 20th century witch-hunt (complete with fictional witches), the
scapegoat conviction of Ellis tainted everyone involved in it, from the
amenable police, right through to the frantic parents - who still somehow
manage to believe that their little darlings were repeatedly and
spectacularly debauched in full view of the passing public
2001-0813 - Waikato
University - The Crucible
The
advertisement clearly shows that the “Peter Ellis experience” is widely
understood to be an experience of injustice, in the same way that Salem 1692,
and the McCarthy hearings in America are also now considered
2001-0726 - Otago Daily Times - Ellis inquiry cost
much less than $500,000 stated
The
ministerial inquiry into aspects of the Christchurch Civic Creche case cost
less than a third of the $500,000 that Justice Minister Phil Goff stated when
he made its report public in March, The Dominion reported this week. Mr Goff
revealed under the Official Information Act that the cost was $148,878.
Former creche worker Peter Ellis, who says he is innocent of charges that he
sexually abused creche children, accused Mr Goff of besmirching him by making
the $500,000 claim
2001-0725 - Waikato
Times - Ellis inquiry costs less than claimed
NZPA - The ministerial inquiry into aspects of the Christchurch Civic Creche
case cost less than a third of the $500,000 that Justice Minister Phil Goff
stated when he made its report public in March.
2001-0724 - Dominion -
Creche inquiry cost less than Goff budgeted
by
David McLoughlin - The ministerial inquiry into aspects of the Christchurch
Civic Creche case cost less than a third of the $500,000 that Justice
Minister Phil Goff stated when he made its report public in March. Mr Goff
revealed under the Official Information Act that the cost was $148,879.
Former creche worker Peter Ellis, who says he is innocent of charges that he
sexually abused creche children, accused Mr Goff yesterday of besmirching him
by making the $500,000 claim
2001-0712 - Marlborough
Express - New wave of innocence
Editorial - A new wave of convicted criminals declaring their innocence can be
expected in the wake of David Dougherty yesterday being paid almost $870,000
in compensation. He also got a public apology for three and a half years he
spent in prison for a crime he did not commit. ……..There seems an increasing trend
for someone to take up the cudgels on behalf of people convicted of high
profile crimes. Joe Karam has become a tireless campaigner on behalf of David
Bain, convicted of murdering his Dunedin family; Peter Ellis had a staunch
support group in his efforts to clear his name in the Christchurch créche sex
abuse case.
|